Skip to content

Menu

LexBlog, Inc. logo
CommunitySub-MenuPublishersChannelsProductsSub-MenuBlog ProBlog PlusBlog PremierMicrositeSyndication PortalsAboutContactResourcesSubscribeSupport
Join
Search
Close

Justice Kelsey’s Dictionaries

By Jay O'Keeffe on May 18, 2021
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn

Join me for a moment in considering Myers v. Commonwealth. Myers is a recent SCOVA opinion reversing a conviction for carrying a concealed weapon in a zippered backpack on the floor of the passenger seat of his car. The relevant statute, Code § 18.2-308, generally bars carrying a concealed weapon but carves out several exceptions.

The exception relevant here, subsection C(8), provides that the statute does not apply to “[a]ny person who may lawfully possess a firearm and is carrying a handgun while in a personal, private motor vehicle or vessel and such handgun is secured in a container or compartment in the vehicle or vessel.”

So the question presented in Myers was whether a handgun in a zippered backpack was “secured.”

It was.

The Court agreed with an earlier opinion out of the Court of Appeals determining that “secured,” as used in the statute, captures a broader category than “locked”: “It necessarily follows that a weapon in a locked container will be secured, but a secured weapon need not be in a locked container.”

Fair enough.

SCOVA also agreed with CAV that “secured” is not the same as “closed,” because to be secured a container must be latched or otherwise fastened.

This brings us to my favorite part of the opinion. Justice Kelsey notes in passing that the CAV’s understanding of the term “secured” comports with “most dictionary definitions.” And what does he cite in support?

See, e.g., 2 Samuel Johnson, A Dictionary of the English Language (1756) (defining “[t]o secure” as “[t]o make fast” (altering archaic spelling)); 2 Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828) (defining “[s]ecured” as “made fast”); Webster’s New International Dictionary of the English Language 1911 (W.T. Harris & F. Sturges Allen eds., 1930) (defining “secure” as “[i]n safe keeping or possession; secured,” “[t]o make fast; to close or confine effectually,” or “[t]o be fastened or secured”); The American Heritage Dictionary 1109 (2d College ed. 1985) (defining “secure” as “[w]ell-fastened” or “[n]ot likely to fail or give way; stable”); Webster’s Third New International Dictionary 2053 (Philip Babcock Gove ed., 2002) (defining “secure” as “to make fast” or “tie down”).

You know you’re getting the deep cuts when you come across a parenthetical “altering archaic spelling.” Someone clearly did their homework. I probably would have gone with Webster’s Third and called it a day, especially given that I am lazy subsection C(8) dates back only to 2010. But I respect the effort and I especially respect that collection of dictionaries.

Chapeau, Justice Kelsey (and/or clerks).

Photo of Jay O'Keeffe Jay O'Keeffe

Jay focuses his practice on appellate litigation and consumer-protection law. He has briefed or argued dozens of cases before the Supreme Court of Virginia, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, and the Court of Appeals of Virginia. He also…

Jay focuses his practice on appellate litigation and consumer-protection law. He has briefed or argued dozens of cases before the Supreme Court of Virginia, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, and the Court of Appeals of Virginia. He also teaches Federal Litigation at UVA law school.

Read more about Jay O'KeeffeEmailJames's Linkedin ProfileJames's Twitter ProfileJames's Facebook Profile
Show more Show less
  • Posted in:
    Appellate
  • Blog:
    De Novo
  • Organization:
    MichieHamlett
  • Article: View Original Source

LexBlog, Inc. logo
Facebook LinkedIn Twitter RSS
Real Lawyers
99 Park Row
  • About LexBlog
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Contact LexBlog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • RSS Terms of Service
  • Products
  • Blog Pro
  • Blog Plus
  • Blog Premier
  • Microsite
  • Syndication Portals
  • LexBlog Community
  • 1-800-913-0988
  • Submit a Request
  • Support Center
  • System Status
  • Resource Center

New to the Network

  • Law of The Ledger
  • Antitrust Law Blog
  • Your ERISA Watch
  • Ciric Law Firm Blog
  • Sacramento Property & Poverty
Copyright © 2022, LexBlog, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo