When offered a severance agreement in Ontario, it is critical to understand what to look for before signing it. Severance agreements often carry legal and financial implications that can affect your future. Knowing the key moments to refuse to sign such as when planning legal action, suspecting insufficient severance pay, or lacking legal representation can help you make an informed decision. This article explores these scenarios and more, ensuring you protect your rights before signing.
Key Takeaways
- Refuse to sign a severance agreement if you plan to pursue legal action or believe the offered amount is insufficient.
- Signing a severance agreement can waive important legal rights and potentially impact your eligibility for Employment Insurance (EI) benefits in Ontario. Legal representation is essential.
- Carefully review the severance agreement and negotiate for better terms, including more pay and extended benefits, before signing.
Key Moments to Refuse Signing a Severance Agreement
Deciding whether to sign a severance agreement requires careful consideration. Certain situations demand that you hold off until you’ve fully reviewed and negotiated the terms. Recognizing these moments can help you avoid signing an unfavourable agreement that compromises your rights.
Severance agreements are often designed to protect the employer, at the expense of the employee’s rights and benefits. Being aware of when to refuse signing helps prevent hasty decisions you might later regret.
Instances to refuse signing include:
1. If You Intend to Pursue Legal Action
Signing a severance agreement in Ontario often means waiving your rights to pursue legal claims against your employer. If you believe you have grounds for legal action due to wrongful dismissal, discrimination, or other workplace issues, signing a severance agreement prematurely could limit your ability to seek justice.
Employers typically include clauses in severance agreements that protect them from future lawsuits. However, some workplace rights, such as certain claims under the Ontario Human Rights Code or statutory severance pay under the Employment Standards Act (ESA), cannot be waived.
Consulting with an employment lawyer before signing ensures you fully understand how the agreement may affect your ability to pursue legal action.
2. When The Severance Package is Insufficient
A fair severance package reflects your employer’s responsibility toward you as an employee and helps provide financial stability during your transition. Unfortunately, many severance packages in Ontario fall short of this ideal.
Under the ESA, employees are entitled to:
- Statutory termination pay: Equal to one week’s pay per year of service (up to 8 weeks).
- Statutory severance pay: For employees with at least five years of service in a workplace with a payroll of $2.5 million or more, equal to one week’s pay per year of service (up to 26 weeks).
In addition, if your employment agreement does not limit your entitlements to the ESA minimums, you may be entitled to common law reasonable notice. Depending on your years of service, position, age, and other relevant factors, you may be entitled to up to 24 months of notice or pay-in-lieu of notice. If the severance package offered doesn’t reflect your years of service, refusing to sign and negotiating for better terms is often the best course of action. An experienced employment lawyer can help assess whether the offer is fair and compliant with Ontario laws.
3. Without Legal Representation
Understanding the terms of a severance agreement is crucial to protecting your rights. Without legal advice, you may overlook critical details that could harm your future.
Employment lawyers in Ontario can:
- Review the agreement to identify any unfair terms.
- Negotiate better terms on your behalf.
- Ensure compliance with the ESA and other applicable laws.
Signing a severance agreement without legal representation can result in unfavourable outcomes, such as accepting a lower severance package than you’re entitled to or waiving important rights.
Potential Downsides of Signing a Severance Agreement
While severance agreements may appear beneficial, they often come with significant downsides. These agreements can limit your future career options, affect your legal rights, and even impact your eligibility for Employment Insurance (EI) benefits in Ontario.
Understanding these potential drawbacks is essential before agreeing to any terms. Here are the key risks:
1. Non-Compete Clauses
Many severance agreements include non-compete clauses, restricting employees from working for competitors or starting a similar business for a specified period. These clauses can significantly limit future employment opportunities, especially in niche industries.
In Ontario, the Working for Workers Act, 2021 prohibits employers from including non-compete clauses in most employment contracts. However, exceptions apply for certain executive positions. Consulting a lawyer ensures you understand whether such clauses are enforceable in your situation.
2. Waiving Legal Rights
Signing a severance agreement may require you to waive certain legal rights, including the ability to file claims for wrongful dismissal or discrimination. While some statutory rights under the ESA and Ontario Human Rights Code are unwaivable, understanding the implications of waiving other claims is essential.
An employment lawyer can help you determine which rights you’re forfeiting and whether the severance offer justifies the waiver.
3. Impact on Employment Insurance (EI) Benefits
In Ontario, receiving severance pay can affect your eligibility for EI benefits. Service Canada may consider severance payments as earnings, delaying or reducing your EI benefits.
Understanding how your severance agreement impacts your EI eligibility ensures you’re prepared for any financial consequences. Consulting a lawyer can help clarify these implications and guide you in negotiating terms that minimize the impact on your benefits.
Evaluating the Fairness of Severance Packages
Evaluating a severance package involves comparing it to industry standards and assessing the overall compensation and benefits offered. A competitive severance package should include financial compensation and additional support measures to ease your transition.
Here are key steps to evaluate fairness:
1. Comparing Industry Standards
Severance packages in Ontario vary by industry and employer. Typical components include:
- One to four weeks of compensation per year of service.
- Payment for unused vacation days.
- Lump-sum payments or salary continuance.
Benchmarking against industry standards ensures your severance package aligns with what others in similar roles receive. Researching your company’s severance policy or consulting an employment lawyer can provide valuable insights.
2. Assessing Compensation and Benefits
Severance pay comes in various forms, such as lump-sum payments or salary continuance. Evaluate all components of the package, including:
- Accrued vacation pay.
- Bonuses.
- Extended health and dental benefits.
If the severance offer falls short, negotiating for better terms is advisable. Highlighting your contributions and achievements can strengthen your case for higher compensation.
3. Legal Representation
Having an employment lawyer review your severance agreement ensures the terms are fair and compliant with Ontario’s employment laws. Lawyers can also identify additional benefits you may be entitled to, such as continued benefits coverage or outplacement services.
Steps to Take Before Signing a Severance Agreement
Before signing a severance agreement, take these critical steps to safeguard your interests:
1. Review the Agreement Thoroughly
Carefully review the terms of the severance agreement to identify any ambiguities or unfavourable clauses. Pay attention to:
- Waivers of legal rights.
- Non-compete clauses.
- Payment structures.
2. Seek Legal Advice
Consulting an employment lawyer is essential to understanding the terms and negotiating effectively. A lawyer can:
- Clarify legal jargon.
- Ensure compliance with the ESA.
- Negotiate better terms on your behalf.
Avoid signing the severance agreement immediately. Taking time to seek legal advice ensures you make an informed decision.
3. Understand Future Implications
Assess how the severance agreement affects:
- Your legal rights.
- EI benefits eligibility.
- Future employment opportunities.
Considering these implications helps you avoid unexpected consequences and ensures the agreement aligns with your best interests.
How to Negotiate a Better Severance Package with Achkar Law
Negotiating a better severance package can lead to significant financial and career advantages. With a strategic approach, you can secure terms that offer greater support during a transition period. Demonstrating confidence and clarity in negotiations often results in more favourable outcomes.
This guide explores key strategies for negotiating severance packages in Ontario, Canada, including increasing severance pay, extending benefits, and customizing departure terms, all while adhering to Ontario’s employment laws.
Increasing Severance Pay
Negotiating severance pay is essential for financial security during your job transition. Under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), employees who have worked for their employer for at least five years and where the employer has a payroll of $2.5 million or more may be entitled to severance pay. This severance pay is in addition to termination pay or notice. However, many employees can negotiate additional severance compensation beyond the minimum standards set by law.
Employees with longer tenures, specialized skills, or a history of substantial contributions can often secure more significant severance packages. Highlight your accomplishments, tenure, and unique contributions to the organization as leverage for a better offer.
It’s also wise to research market standards for severance pay within your industry to determine whether the initial offer aligns with expectations. Armed with this data, you can confidently present a case for a higher severance payment.
Pro Tip: Seek legal advice to evaluate whether the severance offer complies with your entitlements under Ontario law and assess whether you’re eligible for a higher settlement.
Extending Benefits
Negotiating extended benefits is another critical component of severance package discussions. Maintaining access to health insurance and other benefits during your job search can alleviate financial stress.
In Ontario, many employers include benefits such as health, dental, life insurance, and disability coverage in their severance offers. While the ESA does not require employers to continue benefits beyond the statutory notice period, you can negotiate extensions as part of your settlement. For example, request that your employer continue health and dental coverage until you secure new employment.
Key Benefits to Negotiate:
- Health Insurance: Propose continued employer contributions to your health insurance plan.
- Life and Disability Insurance: Ensure protection for unforeseen circumstances during the transition period.
- RRSP Matching or Pension Contributions: Request an extension of contributions if your employer offers these benefits.
Your goal is to extend these benefits long enough to minimize disruptions while you transition to your next opportunity.
Customizing Departure Terms
Customizing your departure terms ensures that your severance agreement protects your career prospects and financial security.
One critical consideration is the inclusion of a reference letter or outplacement services as part of the agreement. These can provide a competitive edge during your job search. Employers often agree to offer support in these areas to facilitate a smoother transition.
Another essential aspect of departure terms is addressing non-compete or non-solicitation clauses. Non-compete clauses may restrict you from working in your industry for a specified period or within a certain geographical area. Under Ontario’s updated Working for Workers Act, 2021, most non-compete clauses are unenforceable except in limited circumstances, such as for executives. If your severance agreement includes such clauses, consult legal counsel to assess their validity and potential impact on your career.
Understanding When Not to Sign a Severance Agreement
It is crucial to understand that signing a severance agreement may have significant legal and financial implications. You should refrain from signing immediately if you plan to:
- Pursue Legal Action: Severance agreements typically include a release clause, waiving your rights to bring any future claims against your employer. If you believe your dismissal violated Ontario’s employment laws, signing a severance agreement may hinder your ability to seek justice.
- Negotiate Better Terms: If the severance offer does not align with your financial needs or industry standards, take time to review and negotiate for improvements.
- Seek Legal Advice: Consult an employment lawyer to review the terms and ensure your rights are protected. A lawyer can identify any provisions that may not comply with Ontario’s laws and help you negotiate a more favourable agreement.
How Severance Agreements Impact Unemployment Benefits
In Ontario, severance payments can affect your eligibility for Employment Insurance (EI) benefits. While a lump sum severance payment does not disqualify you from receiving EI, it may delay the start of your benefits. The duration of the delay depends on the amount of severance pay and your weekly insurable earnings.
Understanding the relationship between severance payments and EI benefits is vital. Reviewing your severance package with an employment lawyer can clarify potential impacts and ensure your financial stability during the transition period.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should I avoid signing a severance agreement if I plan to pursue legal action?
Signing a severance agreement usually includes a release of claims against the employer, preventing you from taking legal action. If you suspect wrongful dismissal or discrimination, consult a lawyer before signing.
What should I do if the severance pay offered is insufficient?
Negotiate for better terms based on your tenure, contributions, and industry standards. An employment lawyer can help you build a strong case for improved severance pay.
Why is it important to seek legal advice before signing a severance agreement?
A lawyer ensures that the agreement complies with Ontario’s laws, protects your legal rights, and helps negotiate more favourable terms, reducing the risk of financial or career setbacks.
How can signing a severance agreement impact my unemployment benefits?
Severance payments may delay your EI benefits. Consult an expert to understand how your severance package affects your entitlement and timing for EI support.
What are non-compete clauses, and how can they affect me?
Non-compete clauses restrict you from working in similar roles for a specified period. In Ontario, most non-compete clauses are unenforceable, but you should seek legal advice to understand their implications.
Conclusion
Negotiating a severance agreement in Ontario requires careful consideration and strategic planning. A severance agreement is more than just a financial settlement; it’s a document that can significantly impact your career and future. By thoroughly reviewing the terms, seeking legal advice, and negotiating improvements, you can turn a challenging situation into an opportunity for a fresh start.
Achkar Law’s employment lawyers specialize in severance package negotiations and can help you navigate the complexities of Ontario employment laws to secure the best possible outcome. Contact us today to protect your rights and safeguard your future.
The post Crucial Times When Not to Sign a Severance Agreement appeared first on Achkar Law.