Rewilding
Enjoy this open access article by Henry Nicholls from PLOS on rewilding:
<>
Restoring Nature’s Backbone
Henry Nicholls
>
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0040202
Copyright:
© 2006 Henry Nicholls. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Nicholls H (2006) Restoring Nature’s Backbone. PLoS Biol 4(6): e202
A herd of bison has just made an extraordinary
migration. The distance these animals travelled was huge—nearly 5,000
miles—and their means of transport was highly unorthodox: they flew.
The cargo plane took some thirty of these hulking mammals from Elk
Island National Park of Canada across Alaskan airspace, over the Bering
Strait, and into the Republic of Yakutia. Their ultimate destination:
the Lenskiye Stolby Nature Park, a 78,500-hectare reserve in northeast
Siberia more commonly known as “Pleistocene Park.”
This is the
latest phase of an experiment to explore the impact of large herbivores
that once roamed these lands on the biodiversity and integrity of the
Siberian steppe ecosystem. One key consequence of putting such
creatures back is that they disrupt the snow cover during the winter,
exposing the ground to the cold and preserving the permafrost. Without
these herbivores, the snow insulates the earth and the permafrost
melts, says Sergei Zimov, director of the Northeast Science Station in
Cherskii, and the brains behind Pleistocene Park. This could allow
microbes to break down vast reserves of carbon contained in the earth,
thereby contributing to global warming, he says [1].
The return of once-native flora and fauna—so-called “rewilding”—should
prevent this and bring the soil much-needed fertilization. “Rewilding
will increase the bioproductivity and biodiversity of the landscape,”
he predicts.
“If we lose these large predators from the ecosystem, biodiversity is the ultimate loser.”
On the Offensive
This
is all part of a proactive approach to nature being articulated with
increasing regularity. Rather than trying to simply ring-fence what
wildlife remains, conservationists need to be restoring whole ecologies
to something of their former glory, says Josh Donlan, an ecologist at
Cornell University (Ithaca, New York, United States). Last year, he and
a long list of high-profile conservation biologists penned a
controversial commentary in Nature in which they laid out the
case for rewilding North America—seeding the continent with suitable
stand-ins for species that went extinct thousands of years ago [2].
Donlan’s
world would see carefully chosen slivers of North America grazed by
giant tortoises, horses, and camels; the stamping ground of elephants
in place of five species of mammoth; and African lions in lieu of the
extinct American lion that once stalked the continent.
The
benefits, they argued, are obvious. It would restore ecological
processes that have gone by the wayside, mend broken evolutionary
relationships, create a back-up population of some of the planet’s most
endangered species, and raise huge awareness for the conservation
cause. “The obstacles are substantial and the risks are not trivial,
but we can no longer accept a hands-off approach to wilderness
preservation,” they wrote of their optimistic vision.
There are
several compelling illustrations of the importance of big creatures for
the integrity of an ecosystem. “There’s more and more evidence that
large vertebrates are disproportionately important not only for
maintaining biodiversity but also for generating biodiversity,” Donlan
says (Box 1).
It’s examples like these that persuade him of the importance of
restoring populations of large vertebrates. “Over the past 30 to 40
years, increasing evidence is showing that if we lose these large
predators from the ecosystem, biodiversity is the ultimate loser,” he
says.
Box 1. The Loss of Tooth and Claw
During the 18th and 19th centuries, overhunting decimated the population of sea otters feeding off the coast of Alaska (Figure 1).
The disappearance of this predator set in motion a top-down cascade
that rippled its way through the kelp forest community. Without otters,
prey species—marine invertebrates like sea urchins, clams, snails, and
crabs—took over, virtually destroying the kelp forests and wiping out
countless ecological niches [3].
Figure 1. Sea Otters
Sea
otters are keystone predators in the kelp forest ecosystem of Alaska,
keeping invertebrate populations in check and thereby maintaining
biodiversity
(Photograph: David Menke, US Fish and Wildlife Service)
Lessons
could also be learned from a long-term study in Venezuela. In the
1980s, a valley was flooded as part of a hydroelectric scheme. This
created Lake Guri, a 4,300-square-kilometer body of water dotted with
hundreds of forested islands of various sizes. Large vertebrates, often
predators, struggled to survive on small islands less than 2 hectares
in size, and in their absence herbivores like leaf-cutter ants thrived (Figure 2).
Conversely, islands of over 75 hectares could accommodate predators,
keeping herbivory in check. By 1997, the density of saplings on small
islands was only 37% of that on large islands. Over the next five
years, small islands lost 46% of their trees and shrubs, compared with
only 32% on large islands [4].
Figure 2. Leaf-Cutter Ants
Leaf-cutter ants can take over when predator pressure is removed
(Photograph: Scott Bauer, US Department of Agriculture)
Broken Links
The
argument for rewilding is also about patching up broken evolutionary
links between species. In New Zealand, for example, there are more than
50 endemic “divaricate” plants—species with thin, interwoven branches
that form a tangled canopy. One explanation for this unusual structure
is that it is an evolutionary adaptation to fend off the herbivorous
approaches of the dozen or so species of flightless moa that went
extinct with the arrival of humans in New Zealand about 1,000 years
ago. Researchers have tested this hypothesis by observing the impact of
emus and ostriches—surviving analogues of the extinct moa—on divaricate
species where juvenile stems are tangled but adults are not (Figure 3). The birds removed 30%–70% less foliage from juvenile shoots than adult shoots [5].
“A large section of the New Zealand woody flora is specifically adapted
to ratite browsing,” says Bill Lee, a plant ecologist at Landcare
Research in Dunedin, New Zealand. “We plan to use emu and ostriches in
experiments in native ecosystems to examine how they modify ecosystem
processes and to investigate their impact on native and introduced
plants with different architectures,” he says.
Figure 3. Ostrich
The ostrich could fill a similar evolutionary niche to the extinct moas of New Zealand
(Photograph: Beth Jackson, US Fish and Wildlife Service)
The
story is similar in the Mascarenes in the Indian cean, where Aldabran
tortoises are being introduced onto a 28-hectare island nature reserve
as proxies for the extinct Geochelone inepta and G. triserrata.
Several native plant species appear to have evolved distinct juvenile
morphological features as a defence against tortoise herbivory. The
introduced tortoises are clearly avoiding these species when they are
in the juvenile stage, says Vikash Tatayah, fauna manager of the
Mauritian Wildlife Foundation (Vacoas, Mauritius).
There are
countless other examples of severed links between species. Donlan and
his colleagues cite the pronghorn, a deer-like mammal that spent more
than four million years on North American grasslands trying to keep one
hoof ahead of the now-extinct American cheetah. This key predator
almost certainly shaped the pronghorn’s astonishing speed, they wrote.
Benchmarks and Proxies
This
sort of proactive vision for conservation raises some tricky questions,
notably those of restoration benchmarks. In North America, conservation
biologists routinely turn to the arrival of Christopher Columbus in
1492, Donlan says. “This is the default benchmark just because it is.”
But, he and his colleagues argued, it would make more ecological sense
to think about the arrival of humans on the continent some 13,000 years
ago. This is the point at which the human-driven extinction of many
large vertebrates contributed to a radical change in the continent’s
wildlife and a rapid loss of biodiversity, he says.
Elsewhere
the appropriate benchmark may be different. David Steadman, curator of
ornithology at the Florida Museum of Natural History (Gainesville,
Florida, United States), has excavated on dozens of islands across the
Pacific Ocean. Soon after the arrival of humans between 30,000 and
1,000 years ago depending on the island, whole swathes of endemic fauna
vanish from the fossil record, Steadman says. As many as 2,000 species
of bird that would probably exist today quickly wound up on the
extinction scrapheap, he says [6].
“Large
vertebrates are disproportionately important not only for maintaining
biodiversity but also for generating biodiversity.”
In
such places, the relatively recent arrival of humans with such dramatic
effects makes a good case for setting a restoration benchmark. In
places like Europe, where humans have been modifying the landscape for
far longer, things are not going to be as clear-cut.
Even if
there is agreement, there is still a debate to be had over the choice
of species for restoration. When a species has disappeared completely,
the idea is to use an ecological analogue or “proxy” for the extinct
species. In some situations, so little choice remains that the decision
is all but made. For example, if scientists ever attempt to restore
flightless rail to the Pacific islands that the fossil record suggests
had them, they will have only a handful of candidate species. “While it
would be nice to be biogeographical purists, we don’t have that luxury
anymore,” Steadman says. But other settings could have many candidate
proxies. It is still not clear whether the candidates should be chosen
for their genetic, behavioural, or ecological similarity to the extinct
species.
Virtual Extinctions
For those studying food
webs—descriptions of who eats whom—it is the ecological services that a
species performs that is crucial. Computer modelling of food webs is a
good way to explore the impact of extinctions on an ecosystem (Figure 4).
“You can take a species on the computer and kill it, but you can’t in
the wild as it’s probably illegal,” says Jane Memmott, a community
ecologist at the University of Bristol (Bristol, United Kingdom). “We
should be conserving ecosystem services and interactions between
species,” she says. “It’s harder to come up with a food-web recovery
plan, but we’re definitely moving in that direction.”
Figure 4. Food Web from a Caribbean Reef
(Image created by software written by R. J. Williams and provided by the PEaCE Lab (http:/
One
of the more robust findings of such virtual worlds is that removing the
most highly connected species causes more secondary, knock-on
extinctions than does the removal of species at random. In certain
webs, large vertebrates can be highly connected. “We can say they
played very important roles and losing them played huge knock-on
effects,” confirms Neo Martinez, director of the Pacific Ecoinformatics
and Computational Ecology Lab (PEaCE; Berkeley, California, United
States). But restoring one or two absent vertebrates to a habitat may
do little to repair an altered food web. “The sort of conditions that
allowed the vertebrates to play their role just aren’t here anymore,”
Martinez says. “We just don’t have enough knowledge about these systems
to predict what would happen. The whole history of trophically oriented
biological control is not pretty.”
“The more extravagant rewilding suggestions presuppose that we know what we’re doing.”
One
way to improve on ecology’s predictive power might be to construct
“paleo food webs,” collating information from the fossil record to
understand the prehistoric interactions between species. Martinez is
one of a handful of scientists interested in this approach. There is a
wealth of paleobiological evidence that can help resurrect extinct food
webs, he says.
Famous fossil ecosystems such as the iconic
Burgess Shale are an obvious place to start. “Even by contemporary
standards of food webs, these are really good data,” Martinez says.
Although much of the bizarre Burgess Shale fauna came to an
evolutionary dead end during the Cambrian period, studying the food web
of an entire suite of species from a long-gone era could help us to
understand how ecosystems have functioned through deep time and reveal
general processes that can and cannot be counted on, he notes. “It
starts to put envelopes around the plausible dynamics of a system.” If
a rewilding initiative were to push that envelope too far, it would be
likely to fail. “The more extravagant rewilding suggestions presuppose
that we know what we’re doing. We don’t,” Martinez says. “Not yet.”
No Alternative
Donlan
is well aware that there are substantial biological, social, and
economic hurdles to clear if rewilding is to take off. It will take
time, careful planning, well-designed experiments, and three stages:
first, the restoration of populations of herbivores as is already
occurring in the Siberian Pleistocene Park; second, rewilding large
protected areas with predators; third, the formation of one or more
“ecological history parks” on, for example, vast tracts of North
America’s Great Plains. The costs and benefits of such proactive
conservation must be carefully calculated on a case-by-case basis. “If
the costs outweigh the benefits, you don’t proceed,” Donlan says. But
the conservation community needs to think carefully about these ideas,
he says. “There are substantial risks of not doing anything.”
Acknowledgments
Competing interests. The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
References
- Zimov SA (2005) Pleistocene Park: Return of the mammoth’s ecosystem. Science 308: 796–798. Find this article online
- Donlan J, Greene HW, Berger J, Bock CE, Bock JH, et al. (2005) Re-wilding North America. Nature 436: 913–914. Find this article online
- Estes
JA, Danner EM, Doak DF, Konar B, Springer AM, et al. (2004) Complex
trophic interactions in kelp forest ecosystems. Bull Mar Sci 74:
621–638. Find this article online - Terborgh
J, Feeley K, Silman M, Nuñez P, Balukjian B (2006) Vegetation dynamics
of predator-free land-bridge islands. J Ecol 94: 253–263. Find this article online - Bond
WJ, Lee WG, Craine JM (2004) Plant structural defences against browsing
birds: A legacy of New Zealand’s extinct moas. Oikos 104: 500–508. Find this article online - Steadman
DW, Martin PS (2003) The late Quaternary extinction and future
resurrection of birds on Pacific Islands. Earth-Science Reviews 61:
133–147. Find this article online
Originally published at lawprofessors.typepad.com
Citation
Environmental Law Prof, Rewilding, Environmental Law Prof Blog (June 13, 2006) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-4ZKC1K4N, lexpid.org/4ZKC1K4N]
Filed under
Practice Area
Companies
Topics
Locations
Organization