Two, Three, Many PassportsMaimon Schwarzschild
Whenever I teach International Law and we come to the topic of citizenship, I poll the class about how many have dual (or multiple) nationality. Until eight or ten years ago, there would only be one or two dual nationals in any class. In recent years it has been creeping steadily upward – last year about 15% of the class, I would guess. I’m teaching the course this semester, and it was that time again this week. I asked for a show of hands: "How many have dual – or multiple – nationality?" This is a pretty big class, about 60 students. More than 25 raised their hands.
Now, a class in Public International Law is obviously not a random sample. These are law students with an interest in international affairs, and hence no doubt with disproportionately international backgrounds. Still. It seems pretty extraordinary to me that nearly half of a relatively large law school class should hold multiple passports.
But perhaps it is not so extraordinary. Dual and multiple nationality is clearly a growing phenomenon. Millions of American citizens now have another nationality as well. (Full disclosure: me too.) It is becoming very common in western Europe as well, and European governments and laws which didn’t tolerate it in the past are increasingly accepting it. So of course is Mexico.
For some dual nationals, the second passport is probably a convenience at most – if it’s an EU passport, a way to travel more easily in Europe and, perhaps as a kid, to get a summer job legally – but not something of great emotional importance or a major factor in who one feels one is. But for others, the sense of multiple attachments, even multiple loyalties, must be stronger.
The optimistic view is that the spread of dual nationality means deeper and stronger ties between countries and across national lines, a less provincial and more cosmopolitan world.
The less optimistic view is that it might also be part of a growing dissolution of sovereignty, even of any sense of strong political community, in many western countries.
I’m not sure how I feel about it. But if a substantial fraction of citizens have multiple allegiances – in their hearts as well as in terms of what passports they carry – it will certainly be a different America, and a different world, from what there has been at least for most of the twentieth century.
Originally published at therightcoastblog.com
Citation
Thomas A. Smith, Two, Three, Many PassportsMaimon Schwarzschild, The Right Coast (October 21, 2007) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-05PRD5WZ, lexpid.org/05PRD5WZ]
Filed under
Practice Area
Locations
Organization