Skip to main content

The Contingency

Aggregation of Aggregate Assets Alright, Second Circuit Holds

By Barry Barnett

Jawcrusher
A jaw crusher doing what it does best.

The Second Circuit today affirmed dismissal of a monopolization complaint against the dominant stone crusher in the New York area.  The big aggregate producer, Tilcon, bought its only competitor in the market; refused to sell rocks to the plaintiff, Port Dock, any more; and jacked up prices.  The district court and court of appeals ruled that Port Dock’s gripe amounted to a refusal-to-deal claim that couldn’t survive a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.  Port Dock lacked “antitrust standing” because its losses resulted not from anticompetitive behavior but from Tilcon’s decision to eliminate distributors and instead to sell directly to end-users.  Port Dock & Stone Corp. v. Oldcastle Northeast, Inc., No. 06-4908 (2d Cir. Oct. 23, 2007).

Barry Barnett

FeediconOur feed enhances your competitiveness.

Originally published at localhost

Citation

Barry Barnett, Aggregation of Aggregate Assets Alright, Second Circuit Holds, The Contingency (October 23, 2007) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-X0942362, lexpid.org/X0942362]

View the record

Filed under