Skip to main content

Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog

Complete Preemption

By Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog

We posted here about Gil Seinfeld’s article The Puzzle of Complete Preemption and interviewed him about it here.  Paul E. McGreal responds to Seinfeld’s position (and that of Trevor Morrison in Complete Preemption and the Separation of Powers) in his brand new paper In Defense of Complete Preemption, published in the University of Pennsylvania Law Review.  The abstract follows.–Counseller

Recent writings by Professors Gil Seinfeld and Trevor Morrison criticize the Supreme Court’s complete preemption doctrine as misguided and unconstitutional, respectively. Professor Seinfeld suggests reforming the doctrine around field preemption, and Professor Morrison rejects complete preemption as inconsistent with separation of powers. This response defends the Supreme Court’s doctrine as it currently stands: A state law claim arises under federal law (and so may be removed to federal court) when a federal statute both preempts the claim and supplies an exclusive federal remedy. This doctrine is a sensible application of the well-pleaded complaint rule that prevents improper circumvention of federal question jurisdiction.   

Originally published at lawprofessors.typepad.com

Citation

Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog, Complete Preemption, Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog (October 24, 2007) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-185HYY84, lexpid.org/185HYY84]

View the record

Filed under