Skip to main content

Federal Eminent Domain Blog

Easement Extortion

By Alan Ackerman

The Pacific Legal Foundation, an outstanding defender of property rights, has taken on a difficult and vexing problem. Frequently, airports demand easements from landowners as a condition of obtaining a building permit or expanding their property use in some fashion. By extorting these easements, government agencies avoid paying just compensation. In these situations, the government would have allowed property modification but for the fact that the land sits in a proposed easement area. Thus, the government is trammeling the rights of an owner by enforcing an otherwise non-existent impediment to property use.   

The North Coast Journal 

In May 2008 the Powells received a certified letter from the Humboldt County Community Development Services Department saying that if they didn’t remedy the zoning violations then the county could declare the additions a public nuisance. The Powells could then be charged for their removal, plus fines, or failing that, “criminal remedies” courtesy of the District Attorney, the letter said. So Powell went back to work on the project, collaborating amicably with the enforcement officer and others in the building department, he said. But he soon came upon the same roadblock he’d hit years earlier.

After submitting a new application for a building permit last year, the Powells received another copy of the overflight easement, along with a demand that it be signed. This time, on the advice of a friend, they contacted the Pacific Legal Foundation, a Sacramento-based nonprofit that specializes in fighting for limited government and individual property rights. On Jan. 12, the PLF filed a lawsuit against the county accusing them of “holding the Powells’ permit application hostage” in violation of both state and federal law — in particular, the U.S. Constitution’s Fifth Amendment clause governing eminent domain.

Originally published at federaleminentdomain.com

Citation

Alan Ackerman, Easement Extortion, Federal Eminent Domain Blog (January 31, 2011) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-WPAT9CZ1, lexpid.org/WPAT9CZ1]

View the record

Filed under