Data Redux
By Chad W. King
CIO Magazine recently discussed four cloud providers that have shut down or are in the process of shutting down, and the difficulties some customers might face as they attempt to extract their data from those vendors. Short of storming the data center and forcibly removing the hard drives, what’s a customer to do when a cloud provider stops returning calls?
A strong contract that requires the vendor to return the data is a must, but even that is only as good as the vendor behind the contact. Even with the most ironclad contract, it can sometimes take days or weeks for a customer to convince a judge to compel the vendor to provide the data, and it might take even longer if the vendor is in bankruptcy. It doesn’t take much imagination to envision a worst-case scenario where the vendor, its creditors or its employees begin removing equipment, deleting data or recommissioning servers before customers even realize there is a problem.
There are certainly legal solutions available in this situation: a temporary restraining order could prevent the removal of equipment and data, and monetary damages or SLA credits might compensate a customer for downtime and loss of data. But those solutions involve making contact with the vendor (hard to do it they are not answering their phone) or getting a court involved (not an inexpensive proposition or a guaranteed outcome). It’s also not going to give senior management much comfort when you tell them “our mission-critical data is gone, but we can sue the vendor.”
To better protect important data, in addition to legal remedies customers should consider including a process in the contract that requires the vendor to periodically send mission-critical data back to the customer or to a trusted third party designated by the customer. With the costs of storage and bandwidth plummeting, it’s becoming much more reasonable to maintain a current or near-current backup copy of most data. Another options is a storage appliance that resides at the customer site and captures snapshots of important customer data.
By making this data backup procedure a contractual requirement, the vendor and customer will both understand what cooperation and action is required of each party, the reports associated with the data delivery, and any costs associated with the backups. This way a customer can rely on the data to be backed up on a schedule, and can be notified if a backup doesn’t occur on time (indicating that the vendor might be experiencing issues that need attention). With a copy of its critical data safely in hand, a customer can still operate its business even if a vendor shuts down, and any legal remedies the customer pursues against a vendor will be the result of careful consideration and cost/benefit analysis, and not a panicked or desperate attempt to retrieve its otherwise irretrievable data.
Originally published at legalcloudcentral.com
Citation
Chad W. King, Data Redux, Legal Cloud Central (June 18, 2011) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-KWZAMH5H, lexpid.org/KWZAMH5H]
Filed under
Practice Area
Organization