In UK News
A report published by the Runnymede Trust on Monday found that black people, and especially black children, are subject to disproportionate rates of strip search across all police forces in England and Wales. The report analysed Home Office data and concluded that black children are 6.5 times more likely to be subject to a strip search than white children, and black adults 4.7 times more likely than white adults. The report described how strip searching “can be severely traumatic and humiliating, particularly for children, with long lasting effects such as anxiety, depression and lower educational attainment”. The Home Office recently a conducted a consultation on proposed reforms to police codes of practice which would create additional protections for children subjected to strip searches, noting that “too often… safeguarding and child protection have not been sufficiently prioritised”. The government’s response is due to be published later this year.
It was the seventh anniversary of the Grenfell Tower fire on Friday. Campaigners from the Infected Blood scandal and the COVID-19 Bereaved Families group joined Grenfell United to call for a national body to scrutinise the implementation of recommendations made following inquests and inquiries. Campaigners said that the lack of oversight prevents lessons being learnt that could prevent future deaths, and argued that if recommendations made by a coroner following the 2009 Lakanal House fire had been implemented, the Grenfell Tower fire might have been avoided. The Grenfell Tower Inquiry’s Phase 2 Report will be published on 4 September.
In international news
Lord Sumption warned that Hong Kong is “slowly becoming a totalitarian state” in an opinion piece explaining his decision to resign from the territory’s final court of appeal. Lord Sumption explained that the “oppressive atmosphere” and challenges such as the “illiberal” national security legislation meant he felt it was no longer realistic to hope that he could help sustain the rule of law as an overseas judge. The government of Hong Kong issued a statement refuting Lord Summation’s comments, stating that any claims of political pressure on judges were “totally baseless”.
In the courts
On Tuesday the European Court of Human Rights handed down judgment in Nealon and Hallam v United Kingdom. Nealon and Hallam spent 17 and 7 years in prison respectively before their convictions were quashed by the Court of Appeal. The two were denied compensation for the time they had spent in prison because they could not prove their innocence beyond all reasonable doubt. The pair argued that once their convictions had been overturned, they should be presumed innocent and that the compensation scheme therefore violated their Article 6 rights. The Court found that Article 6 was engaged, but a majority of 12 found that that the UK’s compensation rules did not breach the presumption of innocence in practice. The Court held that requiring an applicant to show beyond all reasonable doubt that they did not commit an offence was not tantamount to a positive finding that they did the commit the offence. Further, the majority commented that it was not the Court’s role to “determine how States should translate into material terms the moral obligation they might owe to persons who had been wrongfully convicted”. A dissenting judgment of five judges noted that the test in the UK was “virtually insurmountable” and revealed a “highly undesirable attitude towards the presumption of innocence”.
The post The Weekly Round-Up: UK’s wrongful imprisonment compensation scheme is legal and campaigners call for oversight of inquiries appeared first on UK Human Rights Blog.