Skip to main content

Reverse & Render

“Requests for Admission Are A Tool, Not A Trapdoor”

By Byron Henry

In a 6-3 opinion, the Texas Supreme Court held that requests for admissions sent to an insurance carrier in one capacity cannot be used against it in different capacity. USF&G appeared in two capacities represented by two different law firms–as a defendant to the insured’s claim under the underinsured motorist policy and as subrogee to recover funds from the plaintiff. Plaintiff served requests for admission on the firm representing USF&G as subrogee, not as defendant. The Court stated:

Requests for admission are a tool, not a trapdoor. [Plaintiff’s] attorneys knew perfectly well that defendant USF&G was denying underinsured coverage. Accordingly, they are not entitled to use a response against it when they sent it to the law firm representing it in a different capacity.

The majority opinion in United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co. v. Goudeau can be found at this link. The dissent can be found at this link.

Originally published at reverseandrender.wp.lexblogs.com

Citation

Byron Henry, “Requests for Admission Are A Tool, Not A Trapdoor”, Reverse & Render (December 24, 2008) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-B889KHX1, lexpid.org/B889KHX1]

View the record

Filed under