Skip to main content

The Contingency

Downstream Discovery? Magistrate Judge Says No

By Barry Barnett

Magistrate Judge V. Sue Shields yesterday declined to order plaintiffs to provide discovery regarding their “downstream” sales of ready-mix concrete.  The plaintiffs in the case, In re Ready-Mixed Concrete Price-Fixing Litigation, No. 1:05-cv-979-SEB-VSS (S.D. Ind.), allege that Indiana concrete makers, uh, fixed prices.

Whether the victims of any price fixing passed along overcharges to customers doesn’t matter, the Court held.  The plaintiffs may recover the overcharges even if they suffered no loss of profits as a result — courtesy of course of the Illinois Brick doctrine.

Read Her Honor’s scholarly Entry on Motion to Compel here.

And, yes, Blawgletter represents a party to this case, too.

BBar

Feedicon14x14_22Subscribe — for free!

Originally published at localhost

Citation

Barry Barnett, Downstream Discovery? Magistrate Judge Says No, The Contingency (January 18, 2007) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-KXVE0RBX, lexpid.org/KXVE0RBX]

View the record

Filed under