Election Week
Wednesday, October 12, 2016
Election Week
Here is a compromise position on early voting that might bridge the gap between Michael and Lisa’s well-written posts: Election Week. I wrote this piece for Reuters in 2012, but it is just as relevant today. A uniform, nationally-mandated Election Week would help everyone. It would reduce litigation regarding the manipulation of early voting rules. It would focus the country’s attention on a particular, clearly-defined period. It would provide enough time for everyone to participate. Although it might cost states a little extra money to run more precincts throughout the week, the expenditure would be well worth it to remove this aspect of the “voting wars” while still providing enough opportunities to vote.
Here is an excerpt from the column:
On Election Week, polls would be open for seven days, all day for all voters. Beyond taking away one avenue for court involvement in vote-casting disputes, this could offer other significant advantages.
First, it would lead to greater access for more voters, making it easier for Americans to find a time to vote while reducing long lines throughout the week. It is absurd that some citizens have to wait hours in line to vote.
A full week would also avoid problems for religious voters, who might not want to vote on a particular day, while still allowing churches to have “souls to the polls” programs on a Sunday after church.
Second, it would reduce the number of absentee ballots, since more voters will likely be able to find a time to go to the polls.
Third, it could reduce the number of provisional ballots cast – a key area of potential post-election litigation. If voters show up at their precinct without a voter ID, for example, they could return by day seven with the correct documentation.
Fourth, Election Week would lighten the extreme burden on election administrators to run their precincts, tally the results, and announce a winner on a single night.
Fifth, Election Week would ease the hardship on voters dealing with an emergency or disaster, such as New Yorkers or New Jersey voters displaced by Hurricane Sandy.
Read the whole thing here.
Posted by Josh Douglas on October 12, 2016 at 10:18 AM in Law and Politics | Permalink
Comments
It seems, then, that even with election week not every polling station can be open every day for the entire week. Therefore they would have to be open some days. Which means everyone in a specific area will wait for the day that their local station is open (no different from election day), which means that now there has to be different communications for each separate polling station about when that station would be open. And if people missed voting, they would have to drive to the closest open station (in rural districts this could be some distance), and for the voting poor it would be impossible.
Thus, voting week seems like it wouldn’t come close to alleviating Election Day problems, and would probably add some really big extra problems.
Posted by: YesterdayIKilledAMammoth | Oct 13, 2016 12:04:29 AM
“since many on the left deny that there is *any* fraud”
Not just “the left” have looked at the evidence and seen very little in person vote fraud to the degree that an id requirement with the problems including unequal application entails would be good policy. This is not the same as no fraud at all, but that isn’t really necessary when cost/benefit weighing. Cf. “the right” not supporting a gun regulation even if in one or two cases it might be useful. Or, whatever regulation in question.
The comment responded to notes that to the degree there is an issue it’s more like to be present in absentee, which “the left” does sometimes cite to suggest supporters of in person id are not consistent. That makes sense — in person, you have to come and if you fraudulently vote, people see you and you have to in person perhaps (as is NYC practice) sign a book. It’s easier to cheat by absentee to the extent it is done.
====
I vote in NYC and at least for the primary, the school wasn’t closed on the day of voting. I don’t recall what happened time in November, but seems like they could leave a room open for early voting especially if it is smaller than usual since there is less volume over a week’s time. Also, when I lived in another district, it wasn’t a school. So, that’s not always a problem.
Posted by: Joe | Oct 12, 2016 5:06:27 PM
In my state (NY) I’ve always voted in schools that are closed for election day. Where do states physically set up voting booths for an entire week?
“I know that there are many smaller elections at various times of the year, and some of these might fall on religious holidays. But, I don’t think it is very practical to suggest Election Week for every race for County Dogcatcher.”
As an aside, I consider any election that doesn’t occur on election day to be prima facie evidence of corruption. Why are dogcatcher elections on a Wednesday in April in odd years from 2-4 PM at the pound, other than because someone doesn’t want anyone to vote?
Posted by: brad | Oct 12, 2016 3:09:39 PM
Josh,
Thanks for your thoughtful and generous responses.
I have the sense that absentee balloting will be a difficult habit to break/moderate. Election officials seem to like it, and by now, voters in some states are really accustomed to it as a matter of course. You make an interesting point about fraud; in a rational polity that should motivate both sides to migrate voting toward methods that minimize fraud. But, since many on the left deny that there is *any* fraud, and do not seem likely to accept an ID requirement without ongoing challenge, I’m not sure a deal can be made along these lines. On the other side of the coin, absentee balloting used to be something that favored the GOP, which historically had a better GOTV operation. I’m not sure how the GOP feels about it these days – whether the fraud issue or Democratic GOTV parity/over-performance means that the right would be in fact motivated to accept this sort of trade-off.
Posted by: Adam | Oct 12, 2016 11:42:26 AM
Adam,
Thanks for your comment! You make some excellent points. Let me see if I can respond to a few of them…
In terms of reducing litigation, if Congress mandated a uniform Election Week, then that would simply cut off state-by-state litigation on this issue. If we think lots of litigation right before the election is a bad thing, then Election Week could at least stop some of it. I agree that the current litigation is partisan-based, but that does not mean it would be a negative to end it in at least one area.
Resources: yes! This proposal requires more resources, no doubt. In a state like Ohio, with several weeks of early voting, the counties could consolidate their election administration into fewer days. States like New York (or Kentucky) without any early voting would need to spend more. But the current early voting regimes in North Carolina, Ohio, etc. have not broken the bank there. That said, my proposal works only with greater resources for election administration.
Absentee balloting: this part of the proposal is geared specifically toward those who think voter fraud is an actual problem (i.e., it’s an effort to convince Republicans in states with no early voting to sign on). There is not a ton of voter fraud in our system, at least for in-person impersonation, which is the only kind of fraud that a voter ID law would prevent. But there *is* evidence that voter fraud occurs, at least a little bit, with respect to absentee balloting. Election Week, coupled with a requirement that absentee balloting requires an excuse, would thereby reduce the number of absentee ballots and in theory reduce the chance of fraud.
Provisional balloting occurs for a number of reasons, but the two biggest are not having the required ID and not being listed in the poll books (or showing up at the wrong precinct). Election Week would greatly reduce provisional ballots due to lack of ID or showing up at the wrong place. Election Week therefore would reduce the likelihood of needing to resort to provisional balloting, at least for some voters. (Same-day registration would take care of voters who are not in the poll books anywhere.)
My point regarding the hurricane was simply that it would not have been *as* big of a deal if we had an Election Week set up ahead of time. No doubt, the campaigns will litigate for more time (as is occurring in Florida now for voter registration), but at least an institutionalized Election Week would reduce some of that pressure on the system.
In the end, I think your strongest point (among many strong points) is that we would need greater election administration resources to make this a reality. I agree.
Posted by: Josh Douglas | Oct 12, 2016 11:30:46 AM
I think an Election Week would be…fine, but you’re selling it a bit too much here.
Early voting rules? It is beyond laughable that extending voting would impact in the slightest the practical and ideological imperatives that drive this litigation. That is the weakest argument you present here.
I’d like to believe this would help with long lines, and maybe it would. But this phenomenon seems to be driven by consistently poor resource-allocation decisions made by election officials. Extended voting would, paradoxically, invite these officials to allocate fewer resources for each day of the voting period – because not everyone is voting on Tuesday. Long lines are a serious problem, but the answer to them might be something targeted toward the actual problem – too few resources, not too many voters.
Is there evidence of religious voters being reluctant to vote on Tuesdays in November? This week, of all weeks, one might think this was a problem. But the election is a month away. I know that there are many smaller elections at various times of the year, and some of these might fall on religious holidays. But, I don’t think it is very practical to suggest Election Week for every race for County Dogcatcher.
Absentee Ballots? I am skeptical that this demand is sensitive to the number of hours or days a polling station is open. Even if there is no line, and one can walk in on Day 3 of voting, that lessened inconvenience cannot compete with the convenience of voting by mail.
Provisional Ballots? Again – and as this is your area of expertise, I’d ask you to unpack this a bit – but I again think it unlikely that these issues arise because people forgot their ID. The issue as you know is whether they should be required to present it at all. In such states, there will always be plenty of disappointed would-be voters to keep the election-rules challenge industry in business.
Hardship? I agree an extended period would help, but wonder whether it makes sense to institutionalize “emergency” procedures, rather than waiting to see whether they are needed. Maybe there should be an Election Week if there’s a hurricane. But since I’ve suggested that extended voting isn’t “free” – it may exacerbate, rather than solve the problem of poor local decisionmaking – I’m not sure the occasional natural disaster necessitates a permanent change along these lines.
Adam
Posted by: Adam | Oct 12, 2016 11:13:11 AM
The comments to this entry are closed.
Originally published at prawfsblawg.blogs.com
Citation
prawfsblawg@gmail.com, Election Week, PrawfsBlawg (October 12, 2016) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-Q4VR5NZP, lexpid.org/Q4VR5NZP]