Skip to main content

The Faculty Lounge

Decision-Making Styles

I’ve just finished reading the 10th anniversary edition of Difficult Conversations, a business title released by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton and Sheila Heen of the Harvard Negotiation Project. This is a book about how to handle difficult communications in personal and professional life. One issue that caught my attention was a description that appears in the 10th annivesary edition (but not in the earlier edition) about decision-making styles and I was wondering how it might translate to the law school/faculty governance model of decision-making.

Drawing on the work of Mark Gordon, the authors (at p 264 of the text), note that there are at least four different decision-making styles and it is important for the ultimate decision-maker to distinguish between them so there is no confusion about how a decision is being made. The four styles are:

1/ Commanding ie I decide and tell you my decision

2/ Consulting ie I ask for your input, then I decide and tell you the decision

3/ Collaborating/Negotiating ie we decide together

4/ Delegating ie you decide

What is the most effective mode of decision-making in a law school? Do law schools use a combination of these styles? If so, is the dean always clear about which style is being implemented in what circumstances? I’m interested in people’s experiences of decision-making at different schools and under different deans.

Originally published at thefacultylounge.org

Citation

Angelo Carosio, Decision-Making Styles, The Faculty Lounge (February 22, 2011) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-3P0CHJHJ, lexpid.org/3P0CHJHJ]

View the record

Filed under