A New Jersey federal district court recently granted summary judgment in defendants’ favor in an ERISA excessive fee case accusing Evonik’s 401(k) plan fiduciaries of keeping imprudent investments in the plan and of allowing participants to pay excessive recordkeeping fees. Harris,
ERISA Litigation Advisor
News and Insights on the latest ERISA litigation trends for employers
The ERISA Litigation Advisor blog, published by Jackson Lewis P.C., focuses on legal developments and litigation trends related to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). It covers topics such as fiduciary duties, excessive fee litigation, forfeiture disputes, health plan fee challenges, and prohibited transaction claims. The blog analyzes court decisions, circuit splits, and Supreme Court activity affecting ERISA class actions and fiduciary breach claims. It also addresses practical implications for plan sponsors and fiduciaries, including compliance strategies and risk management in retirement and health benefit plans.
Latest from ERISA Litigation Advisor - Page 2
Second Circuit Weighs in Against ERISA Arbitration
Recently, the Second Circuit became the latest circuit refusing to enforce individual arbitration of an ERISA class action, joining the Third, Seventh, and Tenth Circuits. The Ninth Circuit, by contrast, has held that class action ERISA claims brought on behalf…
Where Does the End of Chevron Deference Leave ERISA?
For the last 40 years, judges were required to defer to administrative agencies’ reasonable interpretations of ambiguous federal statutes under Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council. The Supreme Court upended that precedent in Friday’s 6-3 ruling in Loper Bright Enters.…
Conflicting Decisions Foreshadow Upcoming Disputes in ERISA 401(K) Forfeiture Class Actions
Conflicting orders on motions to dismiss from two California courts foreshadow issues for a new theory of ERISA liability. Employers have faced a recent wave of novel ERISA class actions that challenge the reallocation of defined contribution plan forfeitures. Such…
SCOTUS Declines Review of Fourth Circuit ERISA Surcharge Ruling
The U.S. Supreme Court recently declined to hear Rose v. PSA Airlines, Inc., Case No. 23-734, which raised the question of whether a remedy known as “surcharge” falls under ERISA’s equitable remedies provision. Surcharge, in simple terms, resembles monetary damages. …
California District Court Dismisses Conclusory ERISA “Fee” Complaint Unsupported by Facts
A California federal court recently granted an employer win in an ERISA excessive fee case when it dismissed a proposed class action brought by an ex-employee of Schenker, Inc., a transportation logistics company. Partida v. Schenker Inc., No. 22-cv-09192-AMO, 2024…
SDNY Denies Leave to Amend ERISA Complaint with “Substantively the Same Defects” as Dismissed Complaint
A New York federal court recently denied former hospital employees’ request for leave to file a Third Amended Complaint (“TAC”) after dismissing their Second Amended Complaint (“SAC”) for lack of standing and failure to state a claim. Boyette v. Montefiore…
Fourth Circuit Affirms Aon’s Trial Victory in Investment Suit
The Fourth Circuit affirmed Aon Hewitt Investment Consulting’s trial victory in a 250,000-member class action suit alleging that Aon breached ERISA’s fiduciary duties.
Aon was initially the Lowe’s 401(k) plan’s investment advisor and later was engaged as the plan’s 3(38)…
Third Circuit Rejects Mandatory Arbitration Clause in ESOP
The Third Circuit refused to enforce a mandatory arbitration clause with a class action waiver in an ESOP, finding that the class action waiver deprived participants of statutory rights. The ESOP plan added the clause at issue in 2017. When…
Ads Related to Health Plan Fees Raise Questions on the Next Excessive Fee Suit Targets
Is a new wave of ERISA fiduciary litigation targeting group health plan sponsors on the horizon? There have already been a few examples of health plan fee cases, such as claims challenging the billing practice between insurers and their subcontractors…