Statute
35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2)
27 published works
PTAB Litigation Blog
Estoppel Trumps Substance: ITC Bars Respondent’s Invalidity Grounds Raised in IPR
Visit Jones Day's PTAB Litigation blog at www.ptablitigationblog.com. By Evan Tassis and Matt Johnson – Recently, an ITC Administrative Law Judge applied IPR statutory estoppel under 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2)…
Food Safety News
Scientists say animal operations near leafy greens fields are a food safety problem
By Coral Beach
Research published this week shows that animal feeding operations continue to be a problem in terms of E. coli outbreaks linked to leafy greens. As evidenced by outbreaks from Shiga…
Patent Challenges
System Art: Goodbye IPR Estoppel, Hello Fintiv Denials
By Lu Ling (US), Michael Pohl (US), Eagle Robinson (US)
Last week, the Federal Circuit issued a decision in Ingenico Inc. v. IOENGINE, LLC resolving a longstanding district court split by holding that IPR estoppel does not extend to system…
PTAB Litigation Blog
Federal Circuit: Petitioner Estoppel Does Not Apply to Product Prior At Grounds
Visit Jones Day's PTAB Litigation blog at www.ptablitigationblog.com. By Omar Jishi and Matt Johnson – In IOENGINE, LLC v. Ingenico Inc. (Fed. Cir. 2025), the Federal Circuit narrowed the scope…
Intellectual Property Law Blog
A Line in the Sand: Federal Circuit Bounds IPR Estoppel in Ingenico v. IOENGINE
In a significant development for patent litigants, the Federal Circuit in Ingenico Inc. v. IOENGINE, LLC, affirmed an important limitation on the scope of IPR estoppel under 35 U.S.C. §…
Intellectual Property Law Blog
Ironburg Inventions Ltd. v. Valve Corp. 21-2296 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 3, 2023)
By Theo Mayer
This case addresses the “skilled and diligent searcher” standard used for establishing Inter Partes Review (“IPR”) estoppel (or lack thereof). In particular, this case establishes: (1) which party bears the…
Patents Post-Grant
PTAB Estoppel Proof Falls to Patent Owners
By Scott McKeown, Scott McKeown Wolf Greenfield
Burden on Proponent of Affirmative Defense Back in 2016 district courts started encountering infringement suits where the subject patents had survived PTAB challenge. In such scenarios, estoppel applied to failed…
PTAB Law Blog
The Expansion of IPR Estoppel – Potential Win for Patent Owners
Since its inception, the PTAB has gained a negative reputation among patent owners, even being referred to as "patent death squads."[1] However, in the past year the Federal Circuit has…
Patents Post-Grant
Patent Owner Uses FWD Cancelling Claims as a Sword & Shield
By Scott McKeown, Scott McKeown Wolf Greenfield
FWD Statutory Estoppel vs. Collateral Estoppel In designing the America Invents Act (AIA), statutory estoppel of 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2) was set to by legislators to attach at the time…
Patents Post-Grant
PTAB Joinder Provides Estoppel Benefit
By Scott McKeown, Scott McKeown Wolf Greenfield
Joinder Estoppel Narrower Than Original Petition Estoppel Court's have struggled with the meaning of the "reasonably could have raised" aspect of 315(e)(2) IPR estoppel. The CAFC has not had much…