Statute
Chapter 93A
40 published works
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
Mass. Chapter 93A Claims Require Specific In-State Conduct
By David G. Thomas, Angela C. Bunnell
In order to state a viable Chapter 93A, § 11 claim, a plaintiff must make specific, factual allegations about the conduct that occurred primarily and substantially within the Commonwealth of…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
No Business Transaction, No Chapter 93A Claim: Mass. Courts Clarify Requirements
By David G. Thomas, Angela C. Bunnell
To pursue a Chapter 93A claim, there must be some business, commercial, or transactional relationship between the plaintiff(s) and the defendant(s). An indirect commercial link—such as upstream purchasers—may be sufficient to…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
Home Developers Beware: Mass. Appeals Courts Finds Chapter 93A Liability Beyond Contractual Disclosure Requirements
In Tries v. Cricones, home buyers prevailed at trial on their claims against home developers and sellers. Plaintiffs sued because defendants’ failed to disclose that the buyers’ yard was contaminated…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
‘Presentment Requirement’ for Chapter 93A, Section 9 Demand Letters: District of Massachusetts Provides Guidance
The Chapter 93A, Section 9 demand letter presentment requirement allows respondents to evaluate risks and consider pre-suit settlements, as it limits claimants from pursuing relief not specified, thereby potentially avoiding…
Boston ERISA & Insurance Litigation Blog
Principles for Avoiding Chapter 93A or Other Bad Faith Liability (Lesson Three)
In the first of my two posts in this series discussing lessons I have learned over the past thirty years of practice as to how to avoid incurring Chapter 93A…
Boston ERISA & Insurance Litigation Blog
Principles for Avoiding Chapter 93A or Other Bad Faith Liability (Lesson Two)
In my last post on the lessons that I have learned in 30 years of representing insurers in Chapter 93A cases, I discussed the crucial – almost outcome determinative –…
Boston ERISA & Insurance Litigation Blog
Principles for Avoiding Chapter 93A or Other Bad Faith Liability (Lesson One)
I have counseled insurers and represented them in litigation on bad faith claims handling and Chapter 93A cases for pretty much the entire modern era of insurer bad faith law…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
‘Unseemly’ Contract Breach Does Not Automatically Trigger Chapter 93A Liability: Mass. Appeals Court
On Oct. 10, the Massachusetts Appeals Court addressed when a breach of contract violates Chapter 93A in Green Paradise Servs., LLC. V. Hatch Landscape & Design, Inc. In this case,…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
Are ‘Per Violation’ Statutory Penalties Available to Consumers Under Chapter 93A, Section 9?
No. Chapter 93A, Section 9(3) expressly provides for only two forms of recovery: (1) actual damages or (2) $25 in statutory damages, whichever is greater. According to the Massachusetts Supreme…
Massachusetts Chapter 93A Insights
District Court Highlights Time-Honored Chapter 93A Principles in Denying Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
On Sept. 4, 2024, the Hon. Julia E. Kobick issued an opinion detailing some of the fundamental differences between Section 9 (consumer) and Section 11 (business) claims under Chapter 93A.…