Statute
Eighth Amendment
834 published works
Sentencing Law and Policy
Relying on post-<em>Miller</em> legislation, Illinois Supreme Court rules any juve sentence over 40 years constitutes <em>de facto</em> life sentence
I just saw an interesting ruling handed down last week by the Illinois Supreme Court, Illinois v. Buffer, 2019 IL 122327 (Ill. April 18, 2019) (available here), which concerns what…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Henry Montgomery (of <em>Montgomery v. Louisiana</em>) denied parole yet again at age 72
A few years ago Henry Montgomery won in the Supreme Court with his claim that the landmark Eighth Amendment decision in Miller v. Alabama must be applied retroactively. But that…
Supreme Court Update
Bucklew v. Pettigrew (No 17-8151), Biestek v. Berryhill (No. 17-1184), Lorenzo v. SEC (No. 17-1077), Sturgeon v. Frost (No. 17-949)
By David R. Roth, Tadhg Dooley
We’re back with the second installment of our April catch-up series, bringing you summaries of Bucklew v. Pettigrew (No. 17-8151), Biestek v. Berryhill (No. 17-1184), Lorenzo v. Securities Exchange Commission…
Subscript Law Blog
Bucklew v. Precythe (Decision April 1, 2019)
Argument: November 6, 2018Decision: April 1, 2019Petitioner Brief: Russell BucklewRespondent Brief: Anne Precythe, et al. Court below: 8th Circuit Bucklew cannot avoid the state’s standard execution method because of his…
Human Rights at Home Blog
Endorsing Torture: Bucklew v. Precythe
On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its ruling in Bucklew v. Precythe -- a 5-4 decision authored by Justice Gorsuch that goes out of its way to endorse methods tantamount…
Constitutional Law Prof Blog
Court Rejects As-Applied Challenge to Death Penalty Protocol by Prisoner with Rare Medical Condition
Steven D. Schwinn, John Marshall Law SchoolA sharply divided Supreme Court ruled today that a condemned prisoner failed to show that Missouri's lethal injection protocol violated the Eighth Amendment as…
PrawfsBlawg
The Schoolhouse Gate
Main Saturday, March 30, 2019The Schoolhouse GateI've been concentrating on an article draft, but I did find time to read Justin Driver's terrific new book on the Supreme Court's cases…
Sentencing Law and Policy
SCOTUS, ruling 5-3, clarifies execution competency standards and remands in <em>Madison v. Alabama</em>
The Supreme Court this morning handed down an opinion in Madison v. Alabama, 17-7505 (S. Ct. Feb. 27, 2019) (available here), a case concerning the distinctive Eighth Amendment jurisprudence addressing…
Supreme Court Update
Timbs v. Indiana (No. 17-091), Dawson v. Staeger (No. 17-419), Moore v. Texas (No. 18-443)
By David R. Roth, Tadhg Dooley
It’s been a busy week at One First Street, with three opinions, a notable concurrence in a cert denial, and a pair of consequential cert grants. Let’s get you caught…
Consumer Finance Monitor
SCOTUS ruling that Eighth Amendment’s excessive fines prohibition applies to states could provide new weapon to consumer financial services providers
Earlier this week, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Timbs v. Indiana that the prohibition on excessive fines in the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution is incorporated against the…