Topic
Batson Challenges
18 published works
Legal Profession Blog
An All-White Jury
The District of Columbia Court of Appeals will hear oral argument en banc this Thursday reviewing a unanimous opinion rejecting a Batson challenge to an all-white jury in a case…
Understanding the ADA
In a Batson Challenge, what Prosecutor Says is Everything or is It?
Before getting started on the blog entry for the week, I did finish Over Ruled. What is clear from reading the book, is that Justice Gorsuch clearly believes that the…
Legal Profession Blog
Batson And Gender
The Ohio Supreme Court has reversed an appellate decision reversing a conviction for a Batson violation in the peremptory striking of two male jurors in a sexual imposition case.Appellee, Glen…
Presnell on Privileges
Hobson’s Choice? Batson Challenge, Jury-Selection Notes, and Work-Product Waiver
A lawyer defending a Batson challenge to her peremptory juror strikes must present a neutral, non-discriminatory reason for the strike. Often the striking lawyer’s jury-selection notes supply evidence—one way or…
EvidenceProf Blog
Colorado Court of Appeals Finds Trial Court Can’t Rely on Additional Race-Neutral Reasons Given on Remand in Resolving Batson Claim
By Colin Miller
In Batson v. Kentucky, the Supreme Court "ruled that a State may not discriminate on the basis of race when exercising peremptory challenges against prospective jurors in a criminal trial."*…
Simple Justice
A Jury Of Whose Peers?
I never had a problem with Batson, per se. Of course the prosecution shouldn’t discriminate against potential jurors on the basis of race. But its rationale concerned me, creating a…
North Carolina Appellate Practice Blog
The ups and downs (and up again?) of a Batson challenge
In Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment prevents prosecutors in criminal cases from exercising peremptory…
Supreme Court Update
Johnson v. California (03-6539), Scarborough v. Principi (02-1657) and Jones v. R.R. Donnelley & Sons (02-1205)
Greetings Court fans! The Court handed down five opinions today (four from argued cases and one summary reversal) and an order list. With so much ground to cover, I'll divide…
North Carolina Appellate Practice Blog
Petition Allowed: The Beasley Court Adds Its First Discretionary Cases
The Supreme Court released a batch of orders today, denying review in many cases (as usual) but also granting review in six cases. These six grants—the first from the new…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Rounding-up some news and commentary as SCOTUS hears argument on latest round of capital insanity
Albert Einstein is generally credited with the aphorism that "the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again, but expecting different results." That quote came to…