Topic
Brady Violation
86 published works
EvidenceProf Blog
A Proposed Test for How the Court Should Assess the Misleading Disclosure Brady Claim in Adnan’s Case
By Colin Miller
There are three ways that the State can commit a Brady violation:1. The State completely fails to disclose material exculpatory evidence to the defense. See Brady v. Maryland.2. The State makes a…
EvidenceProf Blog
A Brady Violation in Pictures
By Colin Miller
I've gotten a lot of questions about whether Adnan's attorney, Justin Brown, raised a Brady/cell tower/Exhibit 31 claim at the reopened PCR proceedings. Sometimes, a picture really does tell a…
EvidenceProf Blog
A Compelling New Series on Wrongful Convictions by Kristine Guerra of the Indy Star
By Colin Miller
Kristine Guerra, the primary courts reporter for the Indianapolis Star, has started "Stolen Freedom," "an occasional Star series that examines the issue of wrongful imprisonment and shares the stories of people…
EvidenceProf Blog
Why Adnan’s Reopened PCR Proceeding is Not About “Legal Technicalities”
By Colin Miller
We are now just a little over a month away from Adnan's reopened PCR proceeding. At the hearing, Adnan will present evidence and testimony on two claims: (1) he received…
Legal Profession Blog
Missouri Supreme Court Vacates Murder Conviction Based On Brady Violation
In a 4-3 decision, the Missouri Supreme Court overturned a first-degree murder conviction based on a Brady disclosure violation.The court had appointed a special master to take evidence in the…
EvidenceProf Blog
Did the Deputy AG Handling Adnan’s Appeal Withhold Key Brady Evidence in Another Murder Case?
By Colin Miller
In Brady v. Maryland, the Supreme Court declared that the State has an affirmative obligation under the Due Process Clause to disclose material exculpatory evidence to the defense. Sometimes impeachment…
EvidenceProf Blog
Professor Colbert’s Affidavit About the Thoughts of the Jurors After Adnan’s Mistrial
By Colin Miller
In the Addendum to the 11th Episode of the Undisclosed Podcast, we made the argument that the State's misleading disclosures in connection with Exhibit 31 and the cell tower evidence was a Brady violation…
EvidenceProf Blog
Exhibit 31 Was the Cause of the Mistrial at Adnan’s First Trial
By Colin Miller
Last night, we premiered "Exhibit 31," the Addendum to the 12th episode of the Undisclosed Podcast. The episode's title is based upon the key cell tower exhibit that now forms the…
EvidenceProf Blog
Answering Two Questions About the Intersection of CrimeStoppers & Brady
By Colin Miller
Over the past week, I've been following up on Monday's episode of the Undisclosed Podcast and digging into the possible legal implications of the State's failure to disclose that a CrimeStoppers tipster…
EvidenceProf Blog
Baltimore Man Freed After 30+ Years in Prison Based on Numerous Brady Violations After Motion to Reopen
By Colin Miller
In the last night's Addendum Episode of the Undisclosed Podcast, we talked about the Richard A. Nicolas case and the State's failure to disclose two key witness statements. There was another recent…