Topic
Claim Construction
303 published works
IP Wise
A Fraternity of Federal Judges
By Stacy
We’ve mentioned the reversal rates on claim construction before – under the current de novo standard of review (no deference) the Federal Circuit routinely reverses trial judges on claim construction,…
Chicago IP Litigation
Court Construes Distributed Data Storage Patents
Cleversafe, Inc. v. Amplidata, Inc., No. 11 C 4890, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. May 20, 2014) (Lee, J.). Judge Lee construed the disputed claim terms of the patents in this…
New England IP Blog
It’s Situation Normal As Massachusetts Court Declines To Construe Claim Term
Ask each member of a jury to define the word “normally” and you might get twelve different answers. In one recent order, Judge Saylor determined that a jury would understand…
New England IP Blog
Judicial Efficiency: Judges Young and Stearns Agree to Single Claim Construction Hearing
Presiding over separate but related patent infringement suits against tech-industry giants can be neither straightforward nor efficient. The limits of judicial efficiency are further exacerbated when lawsuits involving the same…
Delaware Intellectual Property Litigation
Judge Stark Denies Defendant’s Motion for Reconsideration of Court’s Claim Construction Order
By Memorandum Order entered by The Honorable Leonard P. Stark in Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Actavis, Inc., et al., Civil Action No. 12-993-LPS (D.Del., June 3, 2014), the Court denied…
Delaware Intellectual Property Litigation
Magistrate Judge Burke Issues Report and Recommendation on Claim Construction Ruling on Disputed Terms in Five Patents-in-Suit in Action Against Yahoo!
In Pragmatus AV, LLC v. Yahoo! Inc., Civil Action No. 11-902-LPS-CJB (May 15, 2014), the Honorable Christopher J. Burke issued his Report and Recommendation on the construction of 16 dsiputed…
The Contingency
Supreme Court Tells Federal Circuit to Defer to District Courts on Fee-Shifting Awards
How not to defer. Last month, Blawgletter pointed out that the Supreme Court had granted review in a case that may curb the Federal Circuit. We noted: A rule that…
Essential Patent Blog
Patent Case: Supreme Court to review appellate standard for reviewing district court claim construction (Teva v. Sandoz)
By David Long
Today, in Teva Pharmaceuticals v. Sandoz, Inc., the U.S. Supreme Court granted the petition seeking review of the Federal Circuit's de novo standard of review of a district court's claim…
Chicago IP Litigation
Failing to Offer Construction for Indefinite Term Can Leave a Court “at Sea”
Saro Golf, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., No. 08 C 1110, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Sep. 9, 2013) (Chang, J.). Judge Chang clarified the claim constructions in this patent case regarding…
The Contingency
Deference? I Don’t Have to Show You Any Stinkin’ Deference
A crucial part of a patent case involves the Markman hearing. There, the district judge listens to and sees evidence, PowerPoints, blow-ups, claim charts, and arguments that each side puts forward…