Topic
Confessions
50 published works
The Faculty Lounge
Merging the Reid Technique with Miranda in the Classroom
In prior posts, I argued for why both examples of actual cases such as Brendan Dassey and the Reid interrogation technique belong in the criminal procedure classroom. As promised, in…
The Faculty Lounge
Turning the Corner on False Confessions
As Laura Nirider explained so well yesterday, defense lawyers and some courts have been developing a “new, scientifically-driven awareness of the problem of false confessions.” As though to reinforce Laura’s…
PrawfsBlawg
More from the archives
Main Friday, October 20, 2017More from the archivesTo continue my previous posts on the lost history of police misconduct in Chicago….In 1959, the Illinois ACLU published a small pamphlet—Secret Detention…
PrawfsBlawg
A Bargaining Zone for Miranda Waivers
Main Thursday, December 08, 2016A Bargaining Zone for Miranda WaiversThere has been a lot of action recently in the world of juvenile confessions. Some of it has garnered nation-wide attention,…
EvidenceProf Blog
A Quick Post About the Recent Opinion in the Sabein Burgess Case
By Colin Miller
I don't have much time now, but I wanted to do a quick post about the recent opinion of the United States District Court for the District of Maryland in…
EvidenceProf Blog
Scrutinizing Jay’s Claim That Adnan Confessed to Somebody While Driving Jay to Work
By Colin Miller
Following up on last night's episode of Undisclosed, let's put another of Jay's claims under the microscope. This comes from Jay's second recorded police interview (pg. 64):Jay's claim is that…
EvidenceProf Blog
Liar, Liar: Supreme Court of Missouri Deems Polygraph Evidence Admissible to Prove Defendant Was Lying…Indirectly
By Colin Miller
Under Missouri law, it is well established that "[t]he results of a polygraph examination generally are inadmissible in Missouri criminal trials. Even the fact that a defendant took, refused to…
EvidenceProf Blog
Absof***inglutely: Supreme Court of Canada Creates New Rule of Evidence Deeming Mr. Big Confessions Presumptively Inadmissible
By Colin Miller
The Mr. Big technique is a Canadian invention. Although a version of the technique appears to have been used more than a century ago, its modern use began in the…
Failed Evidence
One Court, One Day, One Issue, Two Cases: Opposite Conclusions on Experts Testimony on Eyewitnesses and Confessions
On May 28, 2014, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court published two opinions about whether juries could hear from experts. In Commonwealth v. Walker, the Court said an expert could tell the jury…
Civil Rights Law & Policy Blog
When police solicit confessions from criminal homicide suspects with lies
The New York Court of Appeals heard oral arguments yesterday in a case to decide whether a confession is coerced when it results from information obtained through a criminal homicide…