Topic
demand futility
32 published works
Commercial Case Notes
Derivative Action Demand Futility Must be Alleged in Complaint, Not Just in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss
By John Lundin
On April 22, 2026, Justice Masley of the New York County Commercial Division issued a decision in Mayer v. Goldner, 2026 NY Slip Op. 31753(U), holding that demand futility in…
Sidley Austin Blog
The Dog That Didn’t Bark: Court of Chancery Decision Reaffirms the Strength of the Demand Futility Standard
By Elizabeth Y. Austin, William J. Lawrence
In July, in Vladimir Gusinsky Revocable Tr. v. Hayes, No. CV 2022‑1124‑MTZ (July 23, 2024), Vice Chancellor Zurn issued an opinion reiterating the high bar a plaintiff must overcome to excuse…
Commercial Case Notes
Demand Futility Allegation Sufficiently Specific Based on Totality of Allegations
By John Lundin
On August 6, 2024, Justice Ruchelsman of the Kings County Commercial Division issued a decision in Kordonsky v. Brudoley, 2024 NY Slip Op. 32768(U), holding that demand futility allegations in…
Sidley Austin Blog
Chancery Court Reminds Bricklayers of Sturdy Foundation Required to Plead Demand Futility for Caremark Claims
By Vincent J. Margiotta, Andrew W. Stern
Last month, in Bricklayers Pension Fund of Western Pennsylvania v. Brinkley, Delaware’s Court of Chancery dismissed a stockholder plaintiff’s derivative suit against the directors and officers of Centene Corporation for…
Delaware Business Dispute Blog
Delaware Chancery Dismisses Complaint for Failure to Adequately Allege Demand Futility
By Carl D. Neff
In the decision of Harrison Metal Capital III, L.P., v. Mathé, et al., C.A. No. 2022-0261-PAF (Del. Ch. Mar. 27, 2024), the Delaware Court of Chancery considered whether plaintiff adequately…
Sidley Austin Blog
Controller’s Ability to Appoint and Remove Directors at Will Insufficient to Establish Demand Futility
In Harrison Metal Capital, an investment fund with an 18% stake in a privately held company called MixMax, Inc. believed the CEO was committing financial improprieties, but found no legal…
Business Litigation Blog
Delaware’s New Universal Demand-Futility Test
On Sept. 23, the Delaware Supreme Court endorsed a new universal three-part demand-futility test in United Food and Commercial Workers Union and Participating Food Industry Employers Tri-State Pension Fund v.…
Delaware Corporate & Commercial Litigation Blog
Should Rales Replace Aronson for Pre-Suit Demand Futility Analysis?
The widely-acclaimed corporate law scholar, and friend of this blog, Prof. Stephen Bainbridge, whose prolific scholarship is cited in Delaware court decisions on corporate law, has penned a brief essay…
Family Business Perspectives
Do Shareholders Need to Make a Demand Upon the Board of Directors Before Filing Suit on a Family-Owned Corporation’s Behalf?
When a shareholder claims that a director or officer has harmed a corporation through his or her improper conduct, these claims typically must be brought through a derivative action, in…
Delaware Chancery Law Blog
Demand Not Excused When “Best Practices” Not Followed
When a derivative lawsuit is brought on behalf of a company, the derivative plaintiff will often times attempt to argue that demand upon the board would be "futile" in order…