Topic
Double Jeopardy
177 published works
Does Crime Pay?
Doubling Down on Double Jeopardy: Federalism at Work in New York
By Mark R. Butscha, Jr., Emily J. Mathieu
Can you be prosecuted twice for the same crime? The question seems simple and, given the plain language of the Fifth Amendment (no person shall “be subject for the same…
Legal Profession Blog
COVID And Double Jeopardy
The New Jersey Appellate Division has held that double jeopardy does not prevent the retrial of a murder charge that was mistried due to the pandemic.A jury had been empaneled…
Lawyers on Strike
Case In Point
By John Regan
We keep sentencing a criminal defendant to more time in prison. Double jeopardy arguments are made, and although obviously correct they are rejected. This one might get corrected because it’s…
Legal Profession Blog
Crime And Punishment In Indiana
The Indiana Supreme Court addressed thorny criminal law issues in two cases decided yesterday.Double jeopardy in the Wadle casewe expressly overrule the Richardson constitutional tests in resolving claims of substantive…
Ohio Appellate Insights
U.S. Supreme Court Requests Response from State to Cert. Petition Filed in Travis Soto Case
Update: On June 22, 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court denied cert. in this case Case Background In 2006, Travis Soto told the police he had accidentally killed his young son…
Ohio Appellate Insights
Oral Argument Preview: Should Prior Acquittal Evidence be Admissible in Subsequent Criminal Trials? State of Ohio v. Michael Smith
Update: On September 22, 2020, the Supreme Court of Ohio handed down a merit decision in this case. Read the analysis here. Read an analysis of the oral argument here.…
Arbitration Matters
Disparate treatment not cured by subsequent modification of earlier discipline, and modification barred by principle of double jeopardy
Two recent arbitration awards involving Cincinnati police officers highlight the issues of double jeopardy and equality of treatment, and the impact of those principles on a Department's efforts to discipline…
Ohio Appellate Insights
Merit Decision: No Double Jeopardy Protection For Man Who Changed Story After Release From Prison About How Son Died. State v. Soto.
“Because Soto entered his guilty plea prior to the empaneling of a jury or the taking of evidence, jeopardy attached—but only as to the child-endangering charge to which he pleaded…
Supreme Court Update
Gross v. FBL Financial Services, Inc. (08-441), Forest Grove School District v. T.A. (08-305) and Yeager v. United States (08-67)
Greetings, Court fans! Welcome back for Part III, which will cover three significant decisions: Gross v. FBL Financial Services, Inc. (08-441), resolving the burden of proof in a "mixed motives"…
Supreme Court Update
United States v. Jimenez Recio (01-1184)
Greetings Court fans! After a long weekend, the Court issued one opinion today, an opinion that falls within the Court's "9th Circuit error correction" jurisprudence. Before I begin, I note…