Topic
Evidence
920 published works
Legal Theory Blog
McBride on Subjective Probabilities and Proof
Ennis McBride has posted Bayes is Bust! Why subjectivism cannot account for the legal concept of 'proof on the balance of probabilities' on SSRN. Here is the abstract: A critique…
Legal Theory Blog
Guerra-Pujol on Evidence and Belief
F. E. Guerra-Pujol (Pontifical Catholic University of Puerto Rico; University of Central Florida) has posted Evidence and Belief: David Hume in the Library of Babel on SSRN. Here is the…
Legal Theory Blog
Allen & Elliott-Smith on Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
Ronald J. Allen (Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law) & Nicolas Elliott-Smith (Northwestern Pritzker School of Law) have posted Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt Doesn't Exist: Except as an Emergent…
EvidenceProf Blog
Supreme Court of Delaware Rules Trial Judge Must Preview Prosecutor’s Video Before Overruling Defense Objection to its Admission
By Colin Miller
Assume that the prosecution plans to introduce a video at a defendant's trial. If the defense objects and the prosecution makes a proffer regarding what the video will depict, can…
EvidenceProf Blog
Court of Appeals of Utah Reverses Manslaughter Conviction Based on Detective Improperly Testifying to Legal Conclusions
By Colin Miller
Similar to its federal counterpart, Utah Rule of Evidence 704(a) states that "An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue." But while witnesses can offer opinion…
EvidenceProf Blog
Supreme Court of Connecticut Finds FitBit Data Was Properly Admitted to Contradict Defendant’s Claim That His Wife Was Killed By An Intruder With a Voice Like Vin Diesel
By Colin Miller
The Supreme Court of Connecticut has affirmed the conviction of Richard G. Dabate for murdering his wife, finding that evidence from her FitBit that contradicted his claims was properly admitted.In…
Legal Theory Blog
Fan on AI-Enhanced Evidence
Mary D. Fan (University of Washington School of Law) has posted AI-Enhanced Evidence (Boston University Law Review, Forthcoming) on SSRN. Here is the abstract: Technological transformations in how we live…
Legal Theory Blog
Giles on Proving Statistical Propositions and Naked Statistical Evidence
Alejo Joaquín Giles (University of Buenos Aires (UBA); University of Girona) has posted A missing piece in the debate about naked statistical evidence (The International Journal of Evidence & Proof,…
Pro Te: Solutio
Turning Up the Heat? Pressure Testing Scientific Theories in Science Days, Rule 702 Hearings, and the Hot Tub
By Butler Snow
Introduction Identifying junk science is merely the first step of the battle when considering argument approach and courtroom strategy. With this in mind, the main goals are to keep junk…
Pro Te: Solutio
Junk Science: What Courts are Seeing and How It Affects Us: A Judge’s Eye View
By Butler Snow
Introduction Trial lawyers, especially defense lawyers in the pharmaceutical and medical device arena, strive to ensure that “junk science” stays out of the courtroom. Unfortunately, that is often wishful thinking.…