Topic
Excessive Fines Clause
77 published works
Agricultural Law & Rural Practice | Solo Small Firm & General Practice Section
Wisconsin Appeals Court Overturns $20,000 Municipal Forfeiture for Parking Commercial Trucks in Residential Area
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals last week held that a $20,000 municipal forfeiture for parking commercial trucks in a residential driveway was unconstitutionally excessive. District 2 Judge Mark Gundrum…
Smith Anderson News
U.S. Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Eighth Amendment Case Supported by Smith Anderson Amicus Brief
Smith Anderson attorneys Hunter Bruton and John Gibbons prepared an amicus brief urging the Court to grant review.The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal from the Alaska…
Simple Justice
The Beer That Cost A Plane
Only 50 years too late, the Supreme Court has granted a petition for certiorari to consider whether the asset forfeiture of a $95,000 plane is excessive for transporting beer to…
Law of the Land
9th Circuit Court of Appeals Holds That Fines Imposed On An Apartment Owner For Tenants’ Unlicensed Short-Term Rentals Did Not Violate The Excessive Fines Clause
This post was authored by Amy Lavine, Esq. The Ninth Circuit considered an Excessive Fines Clause challenge to short-term rental regulations in a 2026 case, Diamond Sands Apartments, LLC v.…
inversecondemnation.com
Eighth Amendment Proprietary: Wine Without the Excessive Fining
Worth checking out: in the vein of our old favorite Eminent Domaine, a Napa Valley winery is offering for preorder its "Eighth Amendment" wine. What's the deal with the name?…
Original Source
District Court Recognizes that Even Minimum FCA Civil Penalties Could Be Unconstitutional Under the Excessive Fines Clause
By Scott D. Stein, Meredith Greene Jalali, Kennedy Cribbs
Recently, the Southern District of New York issued a decision imposing FCA penalties that provides further guidance on the circumstances under which such penalties may violate the Eighth Amendment. In…
Appellate and Supreme Court
“Our Anemic Excessive Fines Clause: Are State Courts Following the Federal Lead?”
The title of this post is the title of this new paper authored by Michael O'Hear and now available via SSRN. Here is its abstract:In 2019, in Timbs v. Indiana,…
Sentencing Law and Policy
"Our Anemic Excessive Fines Clause: Are State Courts Following the Federal Lead?"
The title of this post is the title of this new paper authored by Michael O'Hear and now available via SSRN. Here is its abstract: In 2019, in Timbs v.…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Eleventh Circuit panel finds Excessive Fines Clause applies to FBAR penalties
A helpful reader made sure I did not miss a lengthy new ruling from the Eleventh Circuit late last week in US v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058 (11th Cir. Aug. 30,…
Other
Eleventh Circuit panel finds Excessive Fines Clause applies to FBAR penalties
A helpful reader made sure I did not miss a lengthy new ruling from the Eleventh Circuit late last week in US v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058 (11th Cir. Aug. 30,…