Topic
Harmless Error
49 published works
Sentencing Law and Policy
Notable Fifth Circuit ruling about review of guideline calculation errors
Main December 28, 2010Notable Fifth Circuit ruling about review of guideline calculation errorsI have been remiss in not spotlighting a recent and throughtful panel ruling from the Fifth Circuit about…
Sentencing Law and Policy
California capital case prompts notable statementsupportingdenial of cert
Main November 29, 2010California capital case prompts notable statement supporting denial of certIn with orders and other matters coming from SCOTUS this morning is this statementrespecting the denial of the…
Sentencing Law and Policy
When can (and how eagerly should) circuits declare procedural problems at sentencing mere harmless error?
Main May 11, 2010When can (and how eagerly should) circuits declare procedural problems at sentencing mere harmless error? The question in the title of this post is prompted by a…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Sixth Circuit affirms habeas relief finding Ohio sentencing schemeBlakelyproblematic
Main March 25, 2010Sixth Circuit affirms habeas relief finding Ohio sentencing scheme Blakely problematic The Sixth Circuit has an interesting little opinion today in a habeas case coming from the…
EvidenceProf Blog
The Harmless Conspiracy: Court Finds Harmless Error Despite Improperly Admitted Co-Conspirator Admission
By Colin Miller
Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(2)(E) provides that[a] statement is not hearsay if...[t]he statement is offered against a party and is...a statement by a coconspirator of a party during the course…
EvidenceProf Blog
April Fool’s: California Court Of Appeal Finds Harmless Error In Horribly Misguided April Fool’s Day Appeal
By Colin Miller
Last December, I posted an entry about a horribly misguided opinion of the Court of Appeals of Texas. In that opinion, the court found that the erroneous admission of the defendant's…
Legal Profession Blog
Excessive Rhetoric Harmless Error
The Kansas Supreme Court found plain but harmless error in a prosecutor's closing argument in a felony murder trial. The prosecutor had argued:"They [sic] saying that Brandi shook the baby…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Notable split decision from Eigth Circuit on harmless error sentencing review
Main November 24, 2008Notable split decision from Eigth Circuit on harmless error sentencing reviewThe Eight Circuit has an interesting and thoughtful discussion of sentencing review today in its split decision…
EvidenceProf Blog
Mississippi Burning: Court Of Appeals Of Mississippi Makes Bizarre “Harmless Error” Ruling In Re-Cross-Examination Case
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Court of Appeals of Mississippi in Ronald "Rudy" Moore a/k/a Ronald Moore v. State of Mississippi, 2008 WL 2498240 (Miss.App. 2008), contains both an interesting…
EvidenceProf Blog
I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means: Mississippi Court Misuses Harmless Error Doctrine In Mother’s Day Related Case
By Colin Miller
The Court of Appeals of Mississippi's recent opinion in O'Neal v. State, 977 So.2d 1252 (Miss.App. 2008), stretches the meaning of the term "harmless error." In O'Neal, Shawn Gavin O'Neal…