Topic
Hearsay
406 published works
Ohio Appellate Insights
Merit Decision. “My Gut Reaction is to Subpoena Verizon. ” The Admissibility of Cell Phone Records. State v Hood.
Update: On December 31, 2012, the Supreme Court granted reconsideration in this case and replaced it with Hood II, 2012-Ohio-6208 Read the analysis of Hood II here. On December 3,…
EvidenceProf Blog
Doctor, Doctor, Give Me The News, I’ve Got A Bad Case: Supreme Court Of Tennessee Opinion Addresses Intricacies Of Rule 803(4)
By Colin Miller
Yesterday, I was talking to Derek Black and Claire Raj when we came upon the topic of Federal Rule of Evidence 803(4), which provides an exception to the rule against hearsay forA statement that: (A)…
EvidenceProf Blog
Unauthorized Transfer, Take 6: Second Circuit Applies Transferred Intent Doctrine Of Forfeiture By Wrongdoing
By Colin Miller
Federal Rule of Evidence 804(b)(6) provides an exception to the rule against hearsay for A statement offered against a party that wrongfully caused — or acquiesced in wrongfully causing — the declarant’s…
EvidenceProf Blog
Until My Dying Day: Dying Declarations & Counter-Factual Analysis
By Colin Miller
In yesterday's post, I gave the following hypothetical:Dan robs Vince, with William witnessing the crime. Vince goes to the police and tells them that Dan robbed him. Dan is arrested…
EvidenceProf Blog
Avoiding A Confrontation, Take 3: More Proof That The Bruton Doctrine Is Not A Test Of Constitutional Reliability
By Colin Miller
As I have noted that last couple of days:Pursuant to the Bruton doctrine, the Confrontation Clause is violated by the admission, at a joint jury trial, of a defendant's statement that facially incriminates a…
EvidenceProf Blog
Where The Truth Lies: The Hearsay Problem With Lie Detector Evidence
By Colin Miller
I have been writing quite a bit about lie detector evidence recently and have been mainly focused upon the (un)reliability of such evidence. Until recently, I hadn't really thought about…
EvidenceProf Blog
These Memories Can’t Wait: Michigan Case Reveals Michigan Courts May Have Bungled Rule 803(5) Analysis
By Colin Miller
Similar to its federal counterpart, Michigan Rule of Evidence 803(5) provides an exception to the rule against hearsay forA memorandum or record concerning a matter about which a witness once had knowledge but…
EvidenceProf Blog
Foreign Affairs: 9th Circuit Finds Foreign Record Certification Not “Testimonial” For Confrontation Clause Purposes
By Colin Miller
Federal Rule of Evidence 902(11) provides that the following is self-authenticating:The original or a copy of a domestic record that meets the requirements of Rule 803(6)(A)-(C), as shown by a certification…
EvidenceProf Blog
That’s Just Wrong: Court Of Appeals Of Texas Finds Forfeiture By Wrongdoing Despite No Direct Evidence Of Threat
By Colin Miller
Sticking with the forfeiture theme from the last several days, the recent opinion of the Court of Appeals of Texas, Austin, in Garcia v. State, 2012 WL 3795447 (Tex.App.-Austin 2012),…
EvidenceProf Blog
Unauthorized Transfer, Take 3: Justice Scalia’s Giles Opinion & The Transferred Intent Doctrine Of Forfeiture By Wrongdoing
By Colin Miller
[9/13/12 Update: Here is my essay on the issue: The Purpose Driven Rule: Drew Peterson, Giles v. California, and the Transferred Intent Doctrine of Forfeiture by Wrongdoing]Justice Scalia: I had thought that the…