Topic
Hearsay
406 published works
EvidenceProf Blog
Layering Effect: Ninth Circuit Finds Public Record With Hearsay Within Hearsay Was Improperly Admitted
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Ninth Circuit in United States v. Marguet-Pilado, 2009 WL 792500 (9th Cir. 2009), addresses a topic that I just covered in my Evidence class yesterday: If…
EvidenceProf Blog
Like A Virgin (Islands’ Opinion)?: Supreme Court of V.I. Finds 1953 Uniform Rules Of Evidence Apply In Criminal Trials
By Colin Miller
The 1953 Uniform Rules of Evidence were kind of like Betamax or HD DVD: they just never really caught on and were eventually supplanted by a better competitor. See Michael Teter, Acts of…
EvidenceProf Blog
There’s No Record Of It: Eighth Circuit Seemingly Finds No Criminal Case Exception To Rule 803(10)
By Colin Miller
Back in January, I posted an entry that raised a hypothetical question about the interplay between Federal Rule of Evidence 803(8)(B) and Federal Rule of Evidence 803(10). Well, in its…
EvidenceProf Blog
What’s My Motivation?: Ninth Circuit Applies Former Testimony Hearsay Exception To Grand Jury Testimony
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Ninth Circuit in United States v. McFall, 2009 WL 579508 (9th Cir. 2009), addressed an issue that has split the circuits: When, if ever, can…
EvidenceProf Blog
Don’t Have A Cow: Virginia Judge Excludes Double Hearsay Testimony In Trial Of Animal-Control Officer
By Colin Miller
Last May, Virginia animal-control officer Garland Nester went to kill an errant cow but killed a farmer instead. And now, pursuant to a (correct) ruling by the judge in the…
EvidenceProf Blog
If You Were In The Public Eye: Kentucky Court Finds That Third Party Statements Were Properly Excluded From A Public Report
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Court of Appeals of Kentucky in Adams v. Lexington-Fayette Urban County Government, 2009 WL 350600 (Ky.App. 2009), reveals that simply because third party hearsay is…
EvidenceProf Blog
The Sense Of The Past: Third Circuit Corrects Worst Present Sense Impression Ruling I Have Ever Seen
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Third Circuit in United States v Green, 2009 WL 385423 (3rd Cir. 2009), corrects the worst misapplication of the present sense impression to the rule…
EvidenceProf Blog
Double Coverage: Supreme Court Of Iowa Finds Dying Declaration And Excited Utterance Exceptions Both Applied In Murder Appeal
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Supreme Court of Iowa in State v. Harper, 2009 WL 277087 (Iowa 2009), provides a nice (but disturbing) illustration of something that I teach my…
EvidenceProf Blog
Blue Kentucky Girl: Kentucky Court Finds That Witness’ Incompetence Extends To Her Hearsay Statements
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Court of Appeals of Kentucky in Harris v. Commonwealth, 2009 WL 350615 (Ky.App. 2009), reveals that if a witness is incompetent to testify at trial,…
EvidenceProf Blog
Island Justice: Guam Supreme Court Opinion Reveals Important Hearsay & Confrontation Clause Principles
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of the Supreme Court of the Territory of Guam in People v. Jesus, 2009 WL 259373 (Guam Terr. 2009), reveals important aspects of both the Confrontation Clause…