Topic
Plain Error
57 published works
Paul W. Mollica Federal Courts Blog
Concurring Seventh Circuit Judge Urges Reconsideration of Plain-Error Review Under Fed. R. Crim. P. 29
In United States v. Robinson, No. 24-2310 (7th Cir. Dec. 15, 2025), the Seventh Circuit reverses in part a conviction for bank fraud on sufficiency-of-the-evidence grounds, while a concurring judge…
De Novo
“Plain Error” versus “Fundamental Error”
By Jay O'Keeffe
I was reading through CA4's recent opinion in Le Doux v. Western Express, Inc., ___ F.4th ___ (4th Cir. 2025), when I came across this footnote: Western Express and Worthy…
Criminal
SCOTUS rules defendants must show plain error (and likely won’t) when pressing <em>Rehaif</em> claims on appeal in felon-in-possession cases
The Supreme Court is busy clearing the criminal cases off its docket as the Term winds to a close; today first opinion is unanimously ruling in Greer v. US, No.…
Appellate Law Blog
8th Circuit: Some Insight Into the Plain Error Standard
Appellants try to get trial court judgments reversed. The basic job of appellate judges is to decide, case-by-case, whether a trial judge made an error significant enough to require that…
On Point
SCOTUS will clarify plain error doctrine’s prejudice requirement
By Wisconsin State Public Defender
Greer v. United States, No. 19-8709, cert. granted 1/11/21; SCOTUSblog page Question presented: Whether, when applying plain-error review based on an intervening United States Supreme Court decision, Rehaif v. United States,…
On Point
SCOTUS to address how plain error doctrine applies to defective plea colloquy
By Wisconsin State Public Defender
United States v. Gary, No. 20-444, cert granted 1/8/21; SCOTUSblog page Question presented: Whether a defendant who pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm as a felon, in violation of 18…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Notable SCOTUS summary reversal on plain error review and brief statement on successive federal 2255 review
This mornings order list from the US Supreme Court has a brief summary reversal and an even briefer statement respecting the denial of certiorari. The per curiam decision summary in…
Administrative and Regulatory
Connecticut Supreme Court’s September Term – Week Two
Here’s a look at the second week of the Connecticut Supreme Court’s First Term: Monday, September 23, 2019 The first case of the week is State v. Blaine, S.C. 20087,…
Supreme Court Update
Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Banks (03-892), Illinois v. Caballes (03-923), Howell v. Mississippi (03-9560) and Bell v. Cone (04-3940
Greetings, Court fans! Before heading off for a month-long recess, the Court hit us with four opinions and an order list. Two of the opinions were per curiam, however, so…
Appellate Advocacy Blog
Statements Made in Oral Argument Live Longer than You Might Think.
I am a big proponent of oral argument. It can, and should, make a difference in complicated cases. No matter how tight our writing is, there is something about the…