Topic
Pleadings
194 published works
Commercial Case Notes
Party That Fails to Reject a Late Pleading Waives Right to Seek a Default Judgment
By John Lundin
On June 25, 2025, the Second Department issued a decision in Globalized Realty Group, LLC v. Crossroad Realty NY, LLC, 2025 NY Slip Op. 03797, holding that a party that…
Delaware Corporate & Commercial Litigation Blog
Chancery Denies Motion to Strike Part of Pleading
A recent Delaware Chancery decision is notably for its pithy resolution regarding a rarely used but important procedural rule that, in theory, has wide application. In ZAGG v. Keogh, C.A.…
PrawfsBlawg
Motions to Strike in Action
Main Tuesday, April 29, 2025Motions to Strike in ActionCourts do not often strike (on motion or on its own) under FRCP 12(f), especially an entire pleading. So this one is…
Drug & Device Law
MDL Master Complaint — What’s the Point?
Is the question we are asking ourselves after reading Butler v. 3M Company, 2024 WL 5054884 (S.D. Ohio Dec. 9, 2024). Because if plaintiffs get to amend their complaints post-remand…
Tort Talk
Trial Court Confirms that Defendant Must Plead Facts In Support of New Matter Defenses Asserted
In the case of Kieser v. Beyer, No. CV23-00,923 (C.P. Lyc. Co. Sept. 11, 2024 Lindhardt, J.), the court addressed Preliminary Objections filed against a Defendant’s New Matter in a…
It's Just Business
(Apparent) Litigation by Ambush is Not a Good Tactic in the Business Court
Jeff MacHarg and Alexandra Hirsch Prevailing at summary judgment is rare. Prevailing when there are competing motions on the same issue (fraud) is even rarer. In this opinion, Judge…
Drug & Device Law
N.D. Cal. Gives Plaintiffs a Mulligan on Group Pleading and Jurisdiction
In golf, a mulligan is when a golfer hits a second shot if they're not satisfied with their first shot. We’ve used the term before to refer to the second…
Commercial Case Notes
Amended Complaint May Not Incorporate by Reference Allegations in Original Complaint
By John Lundin
On July 11, 2024, Justice Ruchelsman of the Kings County Commercial Division issued a decision in Gutnick v. Jacobson, 2024 NY Slip Op. 32481(U), holding that an amended complaint may…
PrawfsBlawg
The end of the “obvious alternative explanation” on 12(b)(6)?
Main Friday, May 31, 2024The end of the "obvious alternative explanation" on 12(b)(6)?The idea of an "obvious alternative explanation"--introduced in Twombly and reified in Iqbal--does not fit the 12(b)(6) analysis.…
@theBar
The Value of a Narrative Response in Family Law Cases
By: Judge James A. Shapiro and Adam R. Heusinkveld Family law, which is a civil practice area, falls under the Civil Practice Act. See 750 ILCS 5/105(a) (“The provisions of…