Topic
Standard Essential Patents
442 published works
Essential Patent Blog
European antitrust decisions establish “safe harbour” for willing licensees of standard essential patents
Yesterday, the European Commission issued decisions in two antitrust proceedings centered around the enforcement of standard essential patents (SEPs). The decisions, one involving Samsung and the other Motorola, essentially create…
Essential Patent Blog
Federal Circuit rules no per se prohibition against injunctions for standard essential patents (Apple v. Motorola)
By David Long
Today the Federal Circuit issued its long-awaited decision in the appeal from Judge Posner's ruling that denied both Motorola and Apple damages and injunctive relief in Apple v. Motorola. Among…
China Law Update Blog
Microsoft-Nokia: China’s MOFCOM Quietly Slips Into the Debate about Injunctive Relief for FRAND-encumbered SEPs
This past November and December, the US Department of Justice (“DOJ”) and European Commission (“EC”) cleared Microsoft Corporation’s (“Microsoft”) acquisition of the bulk of the devices and services business of…
Antitrust Law Blog
Microsoft-Nokia: China’s MOFCOM Quietly Slips Into the Debate about Injunctive Relief for FRAND-encumbered SEPs
This past November and December, the US Department of Justice ("DOJ") and European Commission (“EC”) cleared Microsoft Corporation’s (“Microsoft”) acquisition of the bulk of the devices and services business of…
Essential Patent Blog
N.D. Cal. excludes expert damages testimony that based royalty rate on patents’ hold-up value
With standard-essential-patent (SEP) damages discussions frequently focused on how to calculate a RAND rate, one can sometimes forget that not all SEPs are subject to [F]RAND obligations, which raises the issue…
Essential Patent Blog
Jury finds BlackBerry did not infringe NXP’s alleged standard essential patents (NXP v. BlackBerry)
By David Long
Yesterday, a Florida jury returned a verdict that BlackBerry did not infringe NXP's patents alleged to be essential to the IEEE 802.11 WiFi and JEDEC eMMC standards and that the asserted patent claims…
Essential Patent Blog
Update: ITC issues public version of decision to terminate LSI-Realtek investigation (Inv. No. 337-TA-837)
By David Long
The ITC has now released the public version of its decision to terminate the LSI-Realtek investigation without addressing RAND issues, which we discussed in our March 5, 2014 post. The public…
Essential Patent Blog
SanDisk sues PAE Round Rock for antitrust violations, breach of contract involving enforcement of former Micron patents
SanDisk brought suit against Round Rock Research in the District of Delaware last week, alleging that the patent assertion entity's acquisition and enforcement of standard essential patents previously held by Micron…
Essential Patent Blog
Ninth Circuit punts on preliminary injunction that precludes LSI from enforcing any exclusion order (Realtek v. LSI)
By David Long
Well that didn't take long -- yesterday the Ninth Circuit dismissed LSI's appeal from Judge Whyte's preliminary injunction that enjoined LSI from seeking to enforce any exclusion order entered by the…
Essential Patent Blog
Qualcomm and Nokia submit amici curiae briefs to the Federal Circuit in Ericsson v. D-Link appeal
Qualcomm and Nokia weighed-in on the Ericsson v. D-Link appeal yesterday, each filing amici curiae briefs with the Federal Circuit. The parties' positions favored the patent owner, though each adopted…