Topic
Standard Essential Patents
442 published works
Essential Patent Blog
Judge Stark bifurcates Blu-ray SEP case to determine essentiality and FRAND rate before liability issues (One Blue v. Imitation, D. Del. 1:13-cv-917)
By David Long
Yesterday Judge Stark followed an approach used by Judge Holdeman in the Innovatio WiFi case by bifurcating FRAND issues from liability where essentiality and a RAND royalty rate will be…
Essential Patent Blog
American Antitrust Institute Contends Georgia-Pacific Factors Are Innappropriate for RAND-Encumbered Patents (Ericsson v. D-Link, Fed. Cir.)
By David Long
Two weeks ago, we posted about non-party IEEE's amicus curaie brief in Ericsson v. D-Link, et al., an appeal pending before the Federal Circuit. The appeal, initiated by defendants D-Link, Dell, Acer,…
Essential Patent Blog
Funai’s Reply Comments in ITC’s review of RAND ruling in LSI-Realtek investigation (Inv. No. 337-TA-837)
By David Long
We previously discussed the opening comments filed by respondent Funai in the International Trade Commission (ITC) investigation of whether Realtek and Funai infringe complainant LSI’s alleged 802.11 and H.264 standard essential…
Essential Patent Blog
Realtek’s Reply Comments in ITC’s review of RAND ruling in LSI-Realtek investigation (Inv. No. 337-TA-837)
By David Long
A few weeks ago we summarized the opening comments filed by respondent Realtek in the International Trade Commission (ITC) investigation of whether Realtek and Funai infringe complainant LSI’s alleged 802.11 and…
Essential Patent Blog
LSI’s Reply Comments in ITC’s review of RAND ruling in LSI-Realtek investigation (Inv. No. 337-TA-837)
By David Long
We previously discussed the opening comments filed by Complainant LSI in the International Trade Commission (ITC) investigation of whether Realtek and Funai infringe LSI’s alleged 802.11 and H.264 standard essential…
Law Trends
Two Recent District Court Cases Have Made it Clear About RAND Rules
By Miller Nash Graham & Dunn LLP
Two landmark district court cases determined RAND (Reasonable and Non Discriminatory) rates for parties asserting royalties for standard essential patents on RAND terms. One is the Microsoft v. Motorola case…
Essential Patent Blog
Innovatio Settles Litigation with Motorola and SonicWall after RAND Ruling, but Others Remain
By David Long
Since Judge Holderman’s September 27, 2013 order setting a RAND rate in the sprawling Innovatio WiFi litigation (see our October 3 post), two of the five major device manufacturers involved…
Essential Patent Blog
Zenith and MPEG LA move to dismiss ViewSonic’s FRAND-related counterclaims
By David Long
A few weeks ago, we posted about ViewSonic’s FRAND-related counterclaims against Zenith, Panasonic and Philips (collectively, “Manufacturing Plaintiffs”), as well as its FRAND-related Third-Party claim against MPEG LA. On Monday,…
Essential Patent Blog
Microsoft responds that Ninth Circuit jurisdiction is law of the case in RAND dispute with Motorola (Fed. Cir. 14-1089)
By David Long
Last week Microsoft filed a reply supporting its motion to transfer to the Ninth Circuit Motorola's appeal of Judge Robart's RAND ruling (see our prior posts on Microsoft's motion and Motorola's…
Essential Patent Blog
Ericsson asserts that Adaptix is withdrawing its ITC Complaint under threat of a motion for sanctions given unsubstantiated claims (Inv. No. 337-TA-871)
By David Long
Today Ericsson filed its response to Adaptix's sudden motion to withdraw its Complaint and terminate the ITC's investigation of whether Ericsson's base stations infringe an Adaptix patent alleged to cover cellular…