Topic
True Threats
21 published works
Koehler Law Blog
“True Threats” and Stalking in Rokhvand v. Herzfeld
The D.C. Court of Appeals recently clarified what constitutes a “true threat” for purposes of the District’s stalking statute. In Rokhvand v. Herzfeld, 2026 D.C. App. LEXIS 302 (D.C. Aug. 27,…
Media Law Prof Blog
Birnholtz on True Threats, Public Safety, and Free Speech: An Empirical Analysis of Counterman’s Consequences
Jordan Birnholtz, Northwestern University School of Law, is publishing True Threats, Public Safety, and Free Speech: An Empirical Analysis of Counterman's Consequences in the Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology.…
Simple Justice
Short Take: True Threat Or FAFO?
Put aside whether a resolution by the Bakersfield City Council is consequential or performative crap. It’s obviously the latter, as it serves no meaningful purpose other than to reflect its…
Municipal Minute
Supreme Court Settles on Subjective Test for "True Threats" in First Amendment Social Media Case
Today, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling in a Colorado case involving a First Amendment challenge by an individual who had been convicted of stalking for his social media…
Constitutional Law Prof Blog
Court Clarifies True Threats, Requires Subjective Recklessness
The Supreme Court today clarified the "true threats" threats exception to the First Amendment, holding that true threats require that a speaker had a subjective understanding of the threatening nature…
Municipal Minute
U.S. Supreme Court Will Hear "True Threat" First Amendment Case
Today, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral argument in the appeal of a stalking conviction of a Colorado man relating to Facebook posts he made about a local musician.…
Criminal
Preparing for some criminal action as SCOTUS heads into homestretch for OT22
After a couple of (eventful) weeks off, the Supreme Court heads into its last set of oral arguments for the current Term. There are a couple of cases being argued…
On Point
Defense win: Social media posts mixing photos of guns and a crowded theatre was protected speech, not a “true threat”
By Wisconsin State Public Defender
Town of Brookfield v. Martin M. Gonzalez, 2021AP218, District 2, 10/27/21 (one-judge decision; ineligible for publication); case activity (including briefs) Gonzalez posted some photos on Instagram as a “story,” a…
Media Law Prof Blog
Robinson and Hill on The Trouble With “True Threats” @bloglawonline
Eric P. Robinson and Morgan B. Hill have published The Trouble with "True Threats," at 8 UB Journal of Media Law & Ethics 37 (2020). Here is the abstract. In the…
School Law
Connecticut Supreme Court Upholds Expulsion of University Student over True Threat of Gun Violence
By Julie C. Fay, Leander A. Dolphin, Lauren A. Cullen, Joette Katz
The Connecticut Supreme Court has upheld the expulsion of a college student for making statements and gestures that it concluded could reasonably be interpreted as threats that represent unprotected speech…