Topic
Vertical Restraints
94 published works
Antitrust Law Blog
Defendant Sleep Mask Manufacturer Can Sleep Well After Court Puts Exclusive Dealing Claims To Bed
On March 31, 2008, a federal district court in Ohio granted summary judgment after finding insufficient evidence to support a claim that Respironics, Inc., a manufacturer of positive airway pressure devices ("PAPs") and masks…
Retail & Consumer Products Law Observer
Minimum Price Agreements Between Manufacturers and Retailers Are No Longer Per Se Illegal, Now Subject to “Rule of Reason”
Case: Leegin Creative Leather Products, Inc. v. PSKS, Inc., DBA Kay's Kloset, No. 06-480 (U.S. Sup. Ct. 6/28/07)The One Sentence Summary: Reversing 96 years of antitrust precedent that made minimum…
Fashion & Apparel Law Blog
Supreme Court “Discounts” Century-Old Anti-Price-Fixing Rule
On June 28, 2007, a 5-4 Supreme Court ruling in Leegin Creative Leather Products, Inc. v. PSKS overturned almost 100 years of federal precedent by declaring that vertical price fixing…
Antitrust Law Blog
Supreme Court Overrules 96 Year-Old Rule in Dr. Miles and Holds Vertical Price Agreements Are Neither Per Se Illegal Nor Per Se Legal, But Subject to Case-By-Case Test
Summary The Supreme Court has delivered its much anticipated[1] decision in Leegin v. PSKS, Inc.[2] and overruled the 96 year-old rule established in Dr. Miles Medical Co. v. John D.…
Virgin Islands Law Blog
Supreme Court Case Affects Virgin Islands Businesses
By Tom Bolt
Yesterday, in its last business decision of the term, the Supreme Court overruled a nearly century-old rule treating resale price maintenance agreements as per se violations of the antitrust laws.…
The Contingency
Antitrust Update: Dr. Miles to Go Before We Sleep (Update)
Blawgletter has noted that the U.S. Supreme Court ends its public sessions for the 2006 Term tomorrow, June 25, 2007. [The Court announced that it will sit again on Thursday,…
Antitrust Law Blog
Taxicab Company’s Section 1 Challenge to Exclusive Dealing at Airport Yields No Fare
The air in a taxicab company's Sherman Act Section 1 challenge to an exclusive operating agreement between an airport authority and a competing taxicab company went flat when the U.S.…
Antitrust Law Blog
Scent of a Claim: Canada’s Competition Tribunal Holds Sears’ Refusal to Deal Action Lacks Substance
Unlike other areas of antitrust law and policy, Canada is less lenient than United States law when it comes to refusals to deal and resale price maintenance. Since January 2004,…
Antitrust Law Blog
Vaultmaker Claims Exclusive Dealing, but SBC Need Not Accept the Charges
A maker of concrete vaults that house telephone cables cannot add an exclusive dealing claim to the host of antitrust allegations it has leveled against SBC Services Inc., a California…
Antitrust Law Blog
“Well Pleaded Conspiracy to Refuse to Deal with Distributor Survives Motion to Dismiss: The Moral: Just Because Conduct is not “Per Se” Illegal, Does Not Mean That It Is “Per Se” Legal
Plaintiff Bearing Distributors, Inc. (BDI), a dealer, brought an action against Rockwell Automation, Inc. (Rockwell), and a competing dealer, Motion, alleging that Rockwell and Motion conspired to terminate it for refusing…