Topic
Video Evidence
27 published works
Best Practices Construction Law
A Lesson from the Criminal Courtroom to Construction Contractors About Videos and Photos
Yesterday, the Sixth Circuit issued its opinion in Feagin v. Mansfield Police Department et al (Sept. 11, 2025), which involved an excessive force claim by a criminal defendant. Following his…
EvidenceProf Blog
Oregon Judges Denies Motion for New Trial Based on Jurors Zooming in on Video Footage Because the Prosecutors “Hadn’t Done Their Job”
By Colin Miller
Federal Rule of Evidence 606(b) states the following:(b) During an Inquiry into the Validity of a Verdict or Indictment. (1) Prohibited Testimony or Other Evidence. During an inquiry into the…
Paul W. Mollica Federal Courts Blog
District Court Did Not Err in Denying Defense Attorney Leave to Show Previously-Unseen Video Clips During Closing Argument, Holds Eleventh Circuit
In United States v. Simmons, No. 22-12148 (11th Cir. Dec. 6, 2024), the Eleventh Circuit affirms a drug and firearm possession conviction, holding that the district court did not err…
PrawfsBlawg
12(b)(6), summary judgment, and conflicting video
Main Saturday, August 03, 202412(b)(6), summary judgment, and conflicting videoI think the Fourth Circuit reaches the right place--further proceedings required. A trial court can consider a video on a 12(b)(6)…
eDiscovery Bytes
Episode 140: Do You Have a Plan to Preserve Video Evidence? You’ll Need to After You Read This.
In Episode 140, Kelly Twigger reviews the District Court’s decision and discusses why the Court found spoliation of video evidence with intent to deprive, even when the restaurant preserved evidence…
Online Jury Research Update
How are jurors affected by the image size of presented videos? | Online Jury Research Update
Courtroom videos are presented in a variety of ways to jurors, being shown on such devices as small screens in the jury box, big screen television monitors, and large format…
eDiscovery Today Blog
Failing to Record Livestreamed Video is Not Sanctionable, Court Rules: eDiscovery Case Law
By Doug Austin
In Walkie Check Productions, LLC v. ViacomCBS Inc., New York District Court Judge Katherine P. Failla did not find that the defendants had not spoliated evidence in failing to record…
eDiscovery Bytes
Episode 121: Do You Have a Plan in Place to Preserve Video? You’ll Want to in California.
In Episode 121, our CEO, Kelly Twigger discusses how failure to preserve video evidence led to an adverse inference instruction in California State Court even without the required intent showing…
Simple Justice
Short Take: The Death of “But For Video”
When cellphone cameras and video became ubiquitous and police body cams became the norm, video revealed much of what had been adamantly denied. Cops sometimes did bad, and sometimes horrible,…
eDiscovery Today Blog
Default Judgment Against Kitsap County Over Spoliation of Video Evidence: eDiscovery Case Law
By Doug Austin
In Rapp v. Naphcare, Inc., Washington District Judge David G. Estudillo granted the plaintiff’s motion for sanctions, issuing a default judgment against Kitsap County in Washington for spoliation of video…