Skip to content

Menu

LexBlog, Inc. logo
CommunitySub-MenuPublishersChannelsProductsSub-MenuBlog ProBlog PlusBlog PremierMicrositeSyndication PortalsAboutContactResourcesSubscribeSupport
Join
Search
Close

What’s in a name?: Federal Court in Indiana Dismisses Teacher’s Religious Discrimination Over the Use of Students’ Preferred Names

Group of Children in a Circle
By John W. Borkowski, Aleks Ostojic Rushing & Catarina Colón on July 23, 2021
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn

John Kluge, a former music and orchestra teacher at Brownsburg Community School Corporation (“BCSC”) allegedly was forced to resign after refusing to refer to transgender students by the names selected by the students, their parents, and their healthcare providers due to the teacher’s religious objections. Kluge identified as Christian and claimed that referring to students by their preferred names would “encourage students in transgenderism” and “promote gender dysphoria,” which went against his religious beliefs that “God created mankind as either male or female.” Initially, BCSC provided Kluge with the option of referring to students using only their last names, but ultimately, that accommodation was rescinded after several complaints were brought forward from other teachers, students, and parents regarding the negative impacts this practice had on transgender students.

Kluge filed a motion for partial summary judgment, seeking judgment in favor on his failure to accommodate claim and BCSC filed a cross-motion for summary judgment seeking judgment in its favor on both claims. The United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana sided with the school district. In its order, the Court concluded that Kluge had established a prima facie case of discrimination, but that the undisputed evidence also demonstrated that the last-names-only accommodation resulted in undue hardship to BCSC – primarily, because Kluge’s use of the last names hampered BCSC’s ability to provide an education to all students and conflicted with its policy of creating a safe and supportive environment for all students. The Court also noted, “continuing to allow Mr. Kluge an accommodation that resulted in complaints that transgender students felt targeted and dehumanized could potentially have subjected BCSC to a Title IX discrimination lawsuit brought by a transgender student.” According to the Court, the increased risk of liability also constituted an undue hardship that Title VII did not require BCSC to bear.

With respect to Kluge’s retaliation claim, the Court determined that the last-names-only arrangement was withdrawn because of complaints causing undue hardship, not because of any hostility to Kluge’s religious beliefs or because of his request for accommodations.

The Court concluded, “So, what’s in a name?” The Court noted that it “is ill-equipped to answer that question definitively,” but for the reasons the Court articulated in its Order, it concluded that a “name carries with it enough importance to overcome a public school corporation’s duty to accommodate a teacher’s sincerely held religious beliefs against a policy that requires staff to use transgender students’ preferred names when supported by a parent and health care provider.”

What does this mean for you?

This decision will be persuasive precedent for district courts across the country litigating similar issues in the wake of decisions affirming the rights of transgender individuals such as Bostock and Grimm. Consequently, school districts should prepare to address concerns from teachers and staff about their sincerely held religious beliefs related to LGBTQIA+ individuals, while ensuring that their policies and procedures align with these landmark cases.

Photo of John W. Borkowski John W. Borkowski

Coming from a family of teachers, John knows that educators are dedicated to serving students and society. His lifelong passion for education underlies the insightful counsel he provides to colleges, universities and school districts.

Read more about John W. BorkowskiEmailJohn's Linkedin Profile
Photo of Aleks Ostojic Rushing Aleks Ostojic Rushing

As a licensed teacher, Aleks’ passion for education runs deep and is at the core of her work with clients. She knows that every client and every student requires a unique approach to optimize success. Aleks counsels K-12 and higher education clients on…

As a licensed teacher, Aleks’ passion for education runs deep and is at the core of her work with clients. She knows that every client and every student requires a unique approach to optimize success. Aleks counsels K-12 and higher education clients on investigations, litigation and compliance matters arising from a wide range of civil rights and educational funding issues. These include Title IX, Title IV, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Family Educational Records Privacy Act (FERPA).

Read more about Aleks Ostojic RushingEmailAleks Ostojic's Linkedin Profile
Show more Show less
Photo of Catarina Colón Catarina Colón

As an employment-focused litigator and investigator, Catarina advises clients on equal rights, discrimination and retaliation claims, wage and hour issues, Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) matters, and Title VII actions. Catarina also works on the firm’s Higher Education team, assisting clients with…

As an employment-focused litigator and investigator, Catarina advises clients on equal rights, discrimination and retaliation claims, wage and hour issues, Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) matters, and Title VII actions. Catarina also works on the firm’s Higher Education team, assisting clients with extensive employment, student conduct and institutional nondiscrimination efforts. This includes NCAA compliance and investigations into Title IX and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act claims, as well as other federal civil rights statutes and regulations.

Read more about Catarina ColónEmailCatarina's Linkedin Profile
Show more Show less
  • Posted in:
    Education
  • Blog:
    K-12 Legal Insights
  • Organization:
    Husch Blackwell LLP
  • Article: View Original Source

LexBlog, Inc. logo
Facebook LinkedIn Twitter RSS
Real Lawyers
99 Park Row
  • About LexBlog
  • Careers
  • Press
  • Contact LexBlog
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • RSS Terms of Service
  • Products
  • Blog Pro
  • Blog Plus
  • Blog Premier
  • Microsite
  • Syndication Portals
  • LexBlog Community
  • 1-800-913-0988
  • Submit a Request
  • Support Center
  • System Status
  • Resource Center

New to the Network

  • The FTI Award Journal
  • International Dispute Resolution
  • China Law Update Blog
  • Law of The Ledger
  • Antitrust Law Blog
Copyright © 2022, LexBlog, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo