Bankruptcy, Restructuring, and Creditors’ Rights
Will a Creditor be Able to Recover from a Recorded Judgment on a Homestead?
September 27, 2021
Continuing our review of Arizona House Bill 2617 (AZ HB 2617), we will focus our attention on how the Bill impacts creditors. The original blog can be found here.
Creditors have several new collection rights for judgment liens. The first new right is that judgment liens now attach to the homestead property. Before the recently passed AZ HB 2617, a civil judgment created a judgment lien on all real property “except real property exempt from execution, including the homestead property.” The Arizona Legislature removed this language, entitling creditors with valid civil judgments to attach judgment liens to the homestead property. Homeowners no longer own the homestead property free and clear of judgment liens. All civil judgments will create a judgment lien on the homestead property, and all past civil judgments that were not avoided or discharged in a bankruptcy will also become judgment liens on the homestead property.
Judgment creditors now have an entitlement to the proceeds of a homestead property’s voluntary sale. In order to sell the homestead property, a judgment debtor will need to pursue a partial release of a judgment from the title insurer. After deducting the administrative costs of the sale and the amount of any consensual liens do not exceed 80% of the homestead exemption, then the judgment creditor will not receive the amount due under the judgment lien. Accordingly, the title insurer may record a notice of partial release of a judgment. If the sale proceeds are over 80% of the homestead exemption but less than the full amount, the judgment lien is only extinguished if certain conditions are met. One of these conditions is that the title insurer must provide the judgment creditor with twenty days’ written notice. If the judgment creditor objects to the notice with good cause, the title insurer cannot issue a partial release of the judgment lien. The title insurer may issue the partial release if the judgment creditor does not object to the notice. Finally, a title insurer cannot issue a partial release if the judgment debtor will receive more than the homestead exemption. Accordingly, a judgment lien will likely be a hurdle for judgment debtors seeking to sell their homestead property voluntarily.
Judgment creditors are now entitled to be paid in full from any cash proceeds that arise from a judgment debtor’s cash-out refinance of a homestead property. When a judgment debtor receives cash proceeds from refinancing a homestead property with an attached judgment lien, the judgment creditor is now entitled to be paid in full from the cash proceeds. This precludes a judgment debtor from ever collecting cash proceeds through refinancing a homestead property if there is a judgment lien on the property. AZ HB 2617 also modifies that “the homestead exemption does not attach to a person’s interest in identifiable cash proceeds from refinancing the homestead property.” Cash proceeds do not include “monies used to pay direct costs associated with the refinance or to satisfy liens with priority over a judgment lien on a homestead property….”
Judgment debtors will not be able to utilize the homestead exemption as a means of accessing the equity in their homes. Cash proceeds generated through refinancing will have to go towards any judgment liens on the homestead property first. Non cash-out refinances are unaffected.
Stay tuned for the next blog, where we will discuss the impacts AZ HB 2617 has on individual judgment debtors. For more information on AZ HB 2617, please contact Bradley J. Stevens or Joel F. Newell, members of the Jennings Strouss Bankruptcy, Restructuring, & Creditors’ Rights Department.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Joel F. Newell | Read Bio
Bradley J. Stevens | Read Bio
Will Bassoff, Summer Association
About Jennings, Strouss & Salmon, P.L.C.
For almost 80 years, Jennings Strouss has been dedicated to providing clients with strategic legal guidance to help them seize every opportunity. The firm is well-known for its rich heritage, commitment to community, and long-lasting relationships. We have a deep understanding of business and law. When you work with us, you’ll have a team of legal experts who are dedicated to your vision of success.
Through our offices in Phoenix, Peoria, and Tucson, Arizona, and Washington, D.C., we leverage resources both regionally and nationally to serve our expanding client base. Jennings Strouss is deeply rooted in each of our locations’ legal and business communities, and is especially instrumental in helping shape the dynamic growth of Arizona and many of its institutions. The firm promotes a pragmatic, results-oriented approach, coupled with a healthy, well-managed, and friendly atmosphere of collaboration.
Our primary areas of practice include advertising and media law; agribusiness; automobile dealership law; bankruptcy, restructuring, and creditors’ rights; construction; corporate and securities; eminent domain and condemnation; employee benefits and pensions; energy; environmental; estate planning and probate; family law and domestic relations; finance; healthcare; insurance defense; intellectual property; labor and employment; legal ethics; litigation; medical malpractice; mergers and acquisitions; professional liability defense; real estate; surety and fidelity; and tax.
The post Will a Creditor be Able to Recover from a Recorded Judgment on a Homestead? appeared first on Jennings Strouss.