In my prior post, I summarized the analysis in Horton Hatches the Egg: Concerted Action Includes Concerted DisputeResolution, which TimGlynn and I recently uploaded on SSRN. AsI described, we argue that NLRB correctly concluded in In re D.R. Horton that the labor laws protect the right toconcerned action in the form of concerted dispute resolution. We then demonstrate why this right conflictswith and trumps the FAA’s arbitration mandate. Along the way, we discuss why courts confronting the enforceability ofarbitration clauses in employment must address these issues, regardless of whathappens to the Horton decision onappeal.
Ourfinal section addresses the implicationsof our analysis. Courts should refuse to enforce arbitration clauses that, likethe one in Horton, require anemployee to resolve employment-related disputes in individualarbitration and waive the right to pursue joint of collective adjudication ofclaims in any forum. But this does not mean that all arbitration agreements in theemployment context are unenforceable. Agreementsto arbitrate individual claims are enforceable as long as employees are free tobring aggregated claims in court; conversely, employers might well be able tobar access to judicial forums, if they adequately allow for concertedenforcement of legal claims in arbitration.
But, as we demonstrate, there are important limitations onnext-generation arbitration agreements. The NLRA declares it an unfair laborpractice to require agreements that reasonable employees may believe barconcerted action, and, given the Supreme Court’s declaration in Stolt-Nielsen that “arbitration” means “bilateralarbitration,” an agreement providing merely for “arbitration” must barconcerted pursuit of claims. The bottom line is that employers must make clearin their agreements that some form of concerted relief remains available. We wonderwhether most employers will choose to do so. To explore the exciting details, again, youcan check out the article.
Last, but certainly not least, for thoseof you wondering about the title, it’s a play on Dr. Seuss, Horton Hatches the Egg (1940), aclassic children’s tale in which Horton, an elephant, promises to sit on theegg of Mayzie, the lazy bird, while she flies off for a short rest. Needless tosay, Mayzie doesn’t return, but faithful Horton continues to warm the egg fornearly a year, in the process undergoing a variety of ordeals. His performanceis all the more remarkable since Mazie clearly provided no consideration forhis promise.The result is a perhaps genetically unlikely elephant-bird, which might well symbolize the next generation of arbitration agreements if Horton is generally accepted.
CAS
Originally published at lawprofessors.typepad.com
Citation
Workplace Prof, Labor Law Prof Blog (March 21, 2013) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-BT9B2DJT, lexpid.org/BT9B2DJT]
Filed under
Practice Area
Statute
Company
Locations
Organization