Skip to main content

New York City Real Estate Litigator

First Department permits attorneys’ fees by 3-2 vote

By Howard Koh

Graham Court Owner’s Corp. v. Taylor, Appellate DivisionFirst Department 70520/2010

In a 3-2 decision, the First Department has endorsed a broad reading of Real Property Law § 234.  That statute provides for an implied reciprocal right of a residential tenant to recover attorneys’ fees whenever the lease provides that a landlord may recover attorneys’ fees if the tenant fails to perform a lease covenant.    In Graham Court, the lease did not have a traditional landlord’s attorneys’ fees clause.  Rather, the lease provided that any rent the landlord received from re-renting the premises was first to be used to pay the landlord’s expenses.  Expenses was defined to include attorneys’ fees.

“As a remedial statute, Real Property Law § 234 should be accorded its broadest protective meaning. . . . .”

The court held that as a “remedial statute, Real Property Law § 234 should be accorded its broadest protective meaning consistent with legislative intent.” Accordingly, the court ruled that the tenant, who was ultimately successful in his defense of a claim of an unauthorized alteration (the landlord also lost a rent overcharge claim), was entitled to recover attorneys’ fees.  A thorough analysis of the opinion can be found in Warren Estis’s and Michael Feirstein’s New York Law Journal column here.

Because Graham Court was a 3-2 decision, the First Department, may not have the last word on the scope of RPL 234, but, for now, the lesson of Graham Court is that a residential lease that contains a landlord’s prevailing party legal fee clause, no matter how disguised, will likely be read to include an implied reciprocal tenant’s prevailing party legal fee clause.

Originally published at newyorkcityrealestatelitigator.com

Citation

Howard Koh, First Department permits attorneys’ fees by 3-2 vote, New York City Real Estate Litigator (March 3, 2014) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-NRG9CB6W, lexpid.org/NRG9CB6W]

View the record

Filed under