Topic
Claim Construction
303 published works
Chicago IP Litigation
Federal Circuit’s Claim Constructions Control in Remanded Patent Case
The Chamberlain Group, Inc. v. Lear Corp., No. 05 C 3449, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Nov. 24, 2010) (St. Eve, J.). Judge St. Eve ruled on the parties' numerous summary…
Patents Post-Grant
Patent Reexamination Statements Hamper Katz Portfolio
Infamous Katz Portfolio Withers Under Pressure of Patent ReexaminationUSPTO empirical data is quite helpful for determining the frequency by which claims are amended, cancelled, or confirmed in patent reexamination. Yet, when it comes to the overall…
Patents Post-Grant
CAFC Reversal Cites Patent Reexamination Claim Interpretation
Broadest Reasonable Interpretation (BRI) an Outer Limit?In a district court (or the ITC) patent claims are interpreted based upon the presumption of validity accorded issued patents as guided by controlling claim…
Chicago IP Litigation
Claims Construed Narrowly to Avoid Indefiniteness
Only the First, Ltd. v. Seiko Epson Corp., No. 07 C 1333 & 09 C 4655, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Sep. 29, 2010) (Dow, J.). Judge Dow construed the claims…
Patents Post-Grant
Patent Reissue Oaths Can Impact Claim Interpretation
Comparing Claims in Reissue Oath Haunts Patent HolderOn Wednesday, the Federal Circuit reversed a decision of the ITC that excluded the imports of Lucky Litter, LLC. The case (here) related to cat litter boxes having an automated…
Pravel IP Law Blog
CAFC reverses US District Court for the Southern District of California on Claim Construction and Satisfaction of Written Description Requirement
By Jim Pravel
In THE LARYNGEAL MASK COMPANY LTD. AND LMA NORTH AMERICA, INC., v. AMBU A/S, AMBU INC., AND AMBU LTD, 10-1028 (CAFC, September 21, 2010), the CAFC reversed the US District…
Chicago IP Litigation
Court Refers to Input “Directly” Its Claim from the Specification
Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Inc. v. Tech. Research Group, Inc., No. 09 C 3895, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Jun. 28, 2010) (Castillo, J.). Judge Castillo construed the claim terms in this…
Patents Post-Grant
Arguments in Patent Reexamination Trip Up Sigram Schindler
As discussed last week, patent reexamination is often leveraged concurrent with district court litigation for strategic purposes. As district court pendencies continue to rise, even in districts known for relatively speedy resolutions, an…
Patents Post-Grant
BPAI Applies an Implied Claim Construction in Patent Reexamination Appeal
BPAI Affirms Claims of Expired Patent in Ex Parte ReexaminationThe rejection of all claims (save 25, which was confirmed) of expired Patent 4,925,294, (hereinafter, "'294 Patent") owned by Three-Dimensional Media Group…
Delaware Intellectual Property Litigation
Chief Judge Sleet Adopts Magistrate Judge Stark’s Report and Recommendation on Claim Construction
By Order dated June 24, 2010, Chief Judge Gregory M. Sleet adopted the Report and Recommendation Regarding Claim Construction entered by Magistrate Judge Leonard P. Stark on May 12, 2010…