Topic
Claim Construction
303 published works
Patents Post-Grant
Inconsistent Claim Interpretation Practices in Patent Reexamination
DOES THE ORIGINAL PROSECUTION HISTORY FACTOR INTO A BROADEST REASONABLE INTERPRETATION ANALYSIS?It is well established that a broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) claim analysis is applied in both the prosecution of patent applications as well…
Chicago IP Litigation
Claims Need Not Be Construed to Encourage an Embodiment that was Part of a Restriction Requirement
Albecker v. Contour Prods., Inc., No. 09 C 6312, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. May 3, 2010) (Castillo, J.). Judge Castillo construed the claims in this patent case involving a wedge-shaped…
Delaware Intellectual Property Litigation
Chief Judge Sleet Issues Markman Order Incorporating Sanction
In Integrated Discrete Devices, LLC v. Diodes Incorporated, C.A. No. 08-888-GMS (D.Del., May 26, 2010), The Honorable Gregory M. Sleet, Chief Judge, issued the Court's Markman Order construing seven disputed terms…
Delaware Intellectual Property Litigation
JUDGE STARK RESCHEDULES MARKMAN HEARING AS A RESULT OF PLAINTIFF’S FAILURE TO DISCLOSE REBUTTAL EXPERT REPORT
In Biovail Laboratories Int'l SRL v. Cary Pharmaceuticals Inc., C.A. No. 09-605-JJF-LPS (D.Del., May 26, 2010), Judge Stark denied Defendant Cary Pharmaceuticals ("Cary") motion to strike plaintiff Biovail expert's supplemental declaration…
Chicago IP Litigation
Questioning De Novo Claim Construction Review
Trading Techs. Int'l, Inc. v. eSpeed, Inc., Case Nos. 2008-1392,-1393 & -1922, Slip Op. (Fed. Cir. Feb. 25, 2010) (Rader, J.) (Clark, J. concurring). Writing for a panel including Judge…
Patents Post-Grant
CAFC Applies The Wrong Claim Interpretation Standard in Patent Reexamination
In re Suitco Surface, Inc. (Fed. Cir. 2010)Yesterday, the CAFC issued a decision in ex parte reexamination 90/007,015 appeal (U.S. Patent 4,944,514). The decision (In re Suitco Surface Inc) is interesting…
Patents Post-Grant
Expanded BPAI Panel Rehears Reexamination Decision on Expired Katz Patent
On March 15, 2010, an expanded BPAI panel that included Chief APJ, Michael Fleming and Vice Chief APJ, Allen MacDonald rendered a decision on rehearing of an expired patent of the…
Chicago IP Litigation
Court Chooses Dictionary Definitions Over the Parties’ Claim Constructions
totes Isotoner Corp. v. Panther Vision Corp., No. 09 C 1604, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Jan. 4, 2010) (Pallmeyer, J.). Judge Pallmeyer construed plaintiffs' claims for its patent covering headgear…
The Contingency
District Judge, Sitting on Federal Circuit, Fusses About De Novo Review
U.S. District Judge Ron Clark today used his seat on a Federal Circuit panel as soapbox for speaking out against de novo review of Markman rulings. In Markman v. Westview Instruments, Inc.,…
Patents Post-Grant
Final Decision: Ex parte Patrick D. McCarthy
By Naresh Kilaru Danielle Wright Bulger
On September 18, 2009, the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences affirmed-in-part Examiner's rejection of several asserted claims in U.S. Pat. Re. 36,116 under 103(a) obviousness and 102(b) anticipation. The…