Topic
Collateral Estoppel
112 published works
Sentencing Law and Policy
SCOTUS rules 5-4 against finding Double Jeopardy Clause limits prosecutors over severed trials
Main June 22, 2018SCOTUS rules 5-4 against finding Double Jeopardy Clause limits prosecutors over severed trialsThe Supreme Court this morning handed down Currier v. Virginia, No. 16-1358 (S. Ct. June…
Wiley Executive Summary
Collateral Estoppel Bars Relitigation of Issues Bearing on Prior Knowledge of Potential Claim
An Alaska federal court has held that a state court’s finding in the underlying litigation that an insured should have known of a potential claim by a date before inception…
PTABWatch
Collateral Estoppel Not Limited to Identical Claims
The equitable doctrine of collateral estoppel protects a party from having to re-litigate an issue that has already been fully and fairly adjudicated. In Nestlé USA, Inc. v. Steuben Foods,…
Constructlaw®
Connecticut Appellate Court Holds That Owner’s Loss in Arbitration to General Contractor on Claims of Defective Work Operates as Res Judicata to Bar Owner’s Claim Against Subcontractors Who Were Not Parties to the Arbitration
By John Conrad
Girolametti v. Michael Horton Assoc., 2017 Conn. App. Lexis 228 (June 6, 2017) A General Contractor brought claims for unpaid added work, via mandatory arbitration, against a building owner who…
FCA Update
Court Rejects Criminal Defendant’s Attempt to Dismiss Indictment Based on Favorable Defense Verdict in Non-Intervened FCA Case
By Laura McLane
On January 26, 2017, the US District Court for the Western District of Virginia rejected a defendant’s attempt to invoke collateral estoppel principles to dismiss an indictment for fraud. In…
The Faculty Lounge
A Bit More on the OddBravo-FernandezCase
My recent post about the inconsistent verdicts error in the presentation of the Bravo-Fernandez case led to some interesting and illuminating exchanges, some on Twitter (with William Baude and Dan…
Chicago IP Litigation
Intervening Law Negates Collateral Estoppel
Feit Elec. Co. v. Beacon Point Capital, LLC, No. 13 C 9339, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Sept. 30, 2015) (Coleman, J.). Judge Coleman granted in part declaratory judgment plaintiff Feit’s…
Legal Profession Blog
Collateral Estoppel Establishes Ethics Violations
The New York Appellate Division for the First Judicial Department has ordered a two-year suspension of an attorney for misconduct in her own family litigation.The court notedthis Court granted the…
Legal Profession Blog
Use Of Collateral Estoppel In Bar Discipline Upheld
An attorney's frivolous positions and related misconduct merit a five-year suspension imposed by the New York Appellate Division for the First Judicial Departmrnt.The upheld the application of collateral estoppel to…
North Carolina Appellate Practice Blog
Must a North Carolina Court Accept a Twombly-Based Federal Court Ruling as Preclusive on the Merits?
It is beyond dispute that a state court must accord full faith and credit to “the judicial proceedings of the federal courts.” Supreme Lodge, K.P. v. Meyer, 265 U.S. 30,…