Topic
Dissents
71 published works
New York Court Watcher
NYCOA: Criminal Appeals (Part 4b)–Recent Dissents That Should Have Been Majorities
John Marshall HarlanDissented in Plessy A strong dissenting opinion is something to celebrate. (See e.g., discussion in Part 4a.)But, of course, it is often reason for considerable disappointment that it…
Illinois Supreme Court Review
How Has the Length of the Court’s Opinions in Civil Cases Evolved Over Time (Part 2)?
By Kirk Jenkins
In our last post, we addressed the yearly average length of the Court’s opinions in civil cases for the year 1990 through 2003. Today, we’re looking at the years 2004…
California Supreme Court Review
How Was Dissent Distributed in Criminal Cases?
By Kirk Jenkins
This week, we’re following up last week’s posts by taking a closer look at how dissent was distributed at the Court between one, two and three dissenter cases. Today, we’re…
North Carolina Appellate Practice Blog
Dissent Into The Maelstrom
Something not seen in recent years emerged in a recent opinion from the Court of Appeals. In State v. Thabet, COA17-1417 (unpublished) (September 18, 2018), the majority held that defendant’s…
California Supreme Court Review
Does Dissent at the Court of Appeal Predict Division in Criminal Cases at the Supreme Court?
By Kirk Jenkins
Yesterday, we looked at the year-by-year data on the civil side, asking whether the presence of a dissent at the Court of Appeal level is reliably correlated with one or…
Illinois Supreme Court Review
Does Dissent at the Appellate Court Predict Division in Criminal Cases at the Supreme Court?
By Kirk Jenkins
Yesterday, we looked at the year-by-year data on the civil side of the docket, asking whether a dissent at the Appellate Court tends to indicate that one or more dissenters…
California Supreme Court Review
Does Dissent at the Court of Appeal Predict Division in Civil Cases at the Supreme Court?
By Kirk Jenkins
Last time, we tested the often-heard view that a case which didn’t have a dissenter at the Court of Appeal has no chance of getting Supreme Court review. This week,…
Ohio Appellate Insights
Farewell to Bill O’Neill.
Bill O’Neill is gone from the Supreme Court of Ohio. He left to pursue his run for governor. O’Neill’s last day was Friday, January 26, 2018, and his replacement has…
California Supreme Court Review
Are Most of the Court’s Criminal Cases Divided Decisions at the Court of Appeal?
By Kirk Jenkins
In our last post, we reviewed the accuracy of the often-heard suggestion that the Supreme Court only hears cases which drew a dissent at the Court of Appeal. We discovered…
California Supreme Court Review
Are Most of the Court’s Civil Cases Divided Decisions at the Court of Appeal?
By Kirk Jenkins
One of the enduring bits of conventional wisdom that one often hears about California appellate law is that there is no point in seeking Supreme Court review when a case…