Topic
Dissents
71 published works
California Supreme Court Review
Which Justices File Concurrences Most Often in Civil Cases (Part 1 – 2000-2007)?
By Kirk Jenkins
Last week, we completed our analysis of which Justices of the Court have written the most (and least) dissents on both the civil and criminal sides of the docket since…
California Supreme Court Review
Tracking the Justices’ Dissents in Criminal Cases, 2008-2015
By Kirk Jenkins
Yesterday, we reviewed the California Supreme Court’s dissents in civil cases between 2008 and 2015. Today, we turn to the Justices’ dissents in criminal cases for the same years. Justice…
California Supreme Court Review
Tracking the Justices’ Dissents in Civil Cases, 2008-2015
By Kirk Jenkins
Last week, we began our analysis of the Justices’ dissents in civil and criminal cases, looking at the years 2000 through 2007. Today, we turn to the dissents in civil…
California Supreme Court Review
Tracking the Justices’ Dissents in Criminal Cases, 2000-2007
By Kirk Jenkins
This week, we're turning our attention to a new subject, tracking which Justices most often dissented, year by year, and which Justices tended to write the longest and shortest dissents. …
California Supreme Court Review
Tracking the Justices’ Dissents in Civil Cases, 2000-2007
By Kirk Jenkins
Last week, we wrapped up our analysis of the California Supreme Court’s history with amicus briefs. Today, we begin a new topic, tracking which Justices have most frequently dissented, and…
Illinois Supreme Court Review
Are the Illinois Supreme Court’s Dissents Getting Longer (Part 2)?
By Kirk Jenkins
Yesterday, we began our examination of trends in the Illinois Supreme Court’s civil and criminal dissents. We discovered that dissents were at an extremely high level on the criminal side,…
California Supreme Court Review
How Much Does a Dissent at the Court of Appeal Matter for Getting Supreme Court Review in a Civil Case?
By Kirk Jenkins
This week, we’re looking at a new topic in our continuing analysis of the California Supreme Court’s decision making since 2000: how high a fraction of the Court’s civil docket…
Hunton Employment & Labor Perspectives
Viewpoint: The Importance of Dissent at the NLRB
Sitting as the lone dissenter on the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) might seem like a futile exercise. Grinding away on opinions that are critiques of the law as stated…
North Carolina Appellate Practice Blog
What’s Behind the Sharp Rise in Dissents in the North Carolina Court of Appeals?
A dissenting opinion from the North Carolina Court of Appeals goes a long way. Unlike the procedures in many other jurisdictions, a single judge on our intermediate appellate court can…
Illinois Supreme Court Review
Do Dissents at the Appellate Court Reliably Predict Dissent at the Illinois Supreme Court?
By Kirk Jenkins
Yesterday, we began our investigation of the importance of dissents at the Appellate Court for litigation at the Illinois Supreme Court. We demonstrated that the often-heard claim that obtaining review…