Skip to main content

Topic

Estoppel

102 published works

  1. PTABWatch

    Two More District Courts Apply IPR Estoppel to Grounds Not Raised In Petition

    By Julianne M. Hartzell

    As previously discussed in our post covering the state of IPR estoppel, initial district court decisions have varied regarding the scope of IPR estoppel applied to ground for invalidity not…

  2. PTABWatch

    Look to the Claims for Estoppel

    By Julianne M. Hartzell

    In three recent decisions, the Federal Circuit reiterated the importance of determining estoppel in PTAB proceedings on a claim-by-claim basis. In the earlier related decisions, In re Affinity Labs of…

  3. Patents Post-Grant

    Another WiFi One Hint from the CAFC

    By Scott McKeown Wolf Greenfield

    "Closely Tied" Language of Cuozzo & Institution-Centric Statutes The en banc opinion on the scope of the AIA's appeal bar (35 U.S.C. §§ 324(e)/314(d)) remains outstanding in WiFi One.  Still, we…

  4. PTABWatch

    Different Invalidity Conclusions by PTAB and Federal Courts Prohibited

    By Kate Nuehring Su

    In Fairchild (Taiwan) Corp. v. Power Integrations, Inc., Appeal 2017-1002 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 21, 2017), the Federal Circuit determined that no inter partes reexamination proceeding can be brought or maintained on…

  5. PTABWatch

    Joinder Does Not Prevent Application of IPR Estoppel Provision

    By Ryan J. Schermerhorn

    A little more than a month after the Delaware district court narrowly interpreted the IPR estoppel provision to suggest that it may not be necessary to include all known grounds…

  6. Patents Post-Grant

    PTAB Redundant Ground Practice Complicating Estoppel

    By Scott McKeown

    315(e)(2) Estoppel Application Less Than Straightforward IPR estoppel is established under 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2), which provides that “the petitioner in an inter partes review of a claim in a…

  7. PTABWatch

    District Court Interprets the IPR Estoppel Provision Narrowly

    By Sandip H. Patel

    Update (Jan. 13, 2017): The Delaware district court issued a short order on Jan. 11, 2017, maintaining the court’s earlier decision discussed in the post below. An AIA trial is a relatively-inexpensive,…

  8. AIA Blog

    Petitioner Estopped Where Reference Cited in Prosecution History and on Face of Patent-in-Suit Reasonably Could Have Been Raised in Prior IPR

    By Hala S. Mourad

    In Ford Motor Co. v. Paice LLC, IPR2015-00787, Paper 35 (Oct. 21, 2016), the Board dismissed Ford’s inter partes review (IPR) challenge of a claim based on estoppel under 35…

  9. PTABWatch

    Federal Circuit Declares Unreviewable PTAB’s Refusal to Apply Assignor Estoppel

    By Thomas L. Duston

    The Federal Circuit continues to declare aspects of the PTAB’s work to be beyond its review.  Most recently, in Husky Injection Molding Systems Ltd., v. Athena Automation Ltd., Case Nos.…

  10. Blaneys Appeals

    COURT OF APPEAL SUMMARIES (AUGUST 29 – September 2, 2016)

    By John Polyzogopoulos

    Hello everyone. While there were only four substantive civil decisions released by the Court of Appeal this week, three of them were fairly lengthy and of some interest. Victoria University…