Topic
Estoppel
102 published works
Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog
Trial Court Finds Carrier Not Bound by Exclusions Cited in Claims Handling Process and Not Estopped From Raising New Exclusions in Litigation
When I get hired on property damage cases, part of the materials I receive from the policyholder, or the public insurance adjuster, is a full or partial denial letter in…
PTABWatch
Without Estoppel, Are Redundant Grounds Now a Petitioner’s Friend?
The Federal Circuit recently confirmed the Board’s interpretation that § 315(e) estoppel does not take effect with respect to prior art that the Board declines to address as redundant. In…
Patents Post-Grant
PTAB Adds Precedential Decisions
Decisions Clarify Estoppel and 12-month Window Questions Earlier this week I pointed out my Top 5 PTAB decisions for 2015. Also this week, the Board highlighted two of its own…
PTABWatch
Estoppel Applied in Second CBM to Later-Obtained Patent and Evidence
Six days after issuing a final decision holding the claims of U.S. Patent No. 7,711,100 unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 101 in a first CBM review, Square, Inc. v. Unwired…
Zalma's Insurance 101 Videoblog
Insurance 101 – Chapter 6 – Volume 17 – Waiver and Estoppel
By Barry Zalma
Waiver and Estoppel Although the concepts of “waiver” and “estoppel” are usually lumped together, they are totally different concepts that, when applied, result in similar conclusions by a trier of…
PTABWatch
PTAB Refuses to Terminate AIA Trial Despite Applying the Estoppel Provision to Dismiss the Petitioner
The PTAB recently issued an order applying the estoppel provision of the AIA (35 U.S.C. § 325(e)(1)) to dismiss a petitioner from covered business method (CBM) patent review proceedings a…
Patents Post-Grant
PTAB Designates Informative Decisions on Privity & Estoppel
PTAB Announces New Informative Decisions The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has designated the recent decision granting a request for additional discovery in Arris Group, Inc. v. C-Cation Techs.,…
Patent Challenges
PTAB confirms that estoppel does not bar subsequent petitions on non-instituted claims
In Westlake Services, LLC v. Credit Acceptance Corp., the PTAB denied a Patent Owner’s motion to terminate a CBM proceeding, holding that estoppel under 35 U.S.C. § 325(e)(1) does not apply…
PTABWatch
Real Party-In-Interest Not Necessarily Established by Co-Defendants in Litigation
Whether a non-identified party is a real party-in-interest to a proceeding is a highly fact-dependent question. Office Patent Trial Practice Guide, 77 Fed. Reg. 48,756, 48,759 (Aug. 14, 2012) ("Trial…
Patents Post-Grant
Patent Reissue Breadth Anchored to Previous Markman Construction
CAFC Decides Patent Reissue was Improperly Broadened Based on Previous Markman Definition Yesterday, in ArcelorMittal France v. AK Steel Corp. (CAFC 2015), the CAFC considered the impact of a reissue of…