Topic
Hearsay
406 published works
EvidenceProf Blog
True Confessions: Court of Appeals Of Texas Finds Cleric-Penitent Privilege Doesn’t Apply To Confessions In The Church Of Christ
By Colin Miller
A murder case in Houston has produced an interesting evidentiary ruling under Texas' clergy-penitent privilege. In Leach v. State, 2008 WL 4075797 (Tex.App.-Hous. 2008), Dan Randall Leach II confessed to…
EvidenceProf Blog
The Turncoat CI: 3rd Circuit Corrects Trial Judge’s Erroneous Hearsay Ruling In Drug Bust
By Colin Miller
The Third Circuit's recent opinion in United States v. Green, 2008 WL 4014129 (3rd Cir. 2008), involves a confidential informant going turncoat, the prosecution scrambling to discredit him, and the…
EvidenceProf Blog
This Land Is Your Land, This Land Is My Land: Court Of Federal Claims Hears Pearl Harbor Land Dispute Despite Hearsay Claims
By Colin Miller
The Court of Federal Claims is currently hearing a case involving an interesting piece of history. In 1942 and 1943, in the wake of Pearl Harbor, government agents apparently arrived…
EvidenceProf Blog
Rescue 911: Court Of Appeals Of Virginia Finds 911 Call Satisfies Excited Utterance Exception And Confrontation Clause
By Colin Miller
The Court of Appeals of Virginia's recent opinion in Caison v. Commonwealth, 2008 WL 2884089 (Va.App. 2008), seems to be directly in line with the opinion of the United State's…
EvidenceProf Blog
Evidence Laws Turned Upside Down Down Under?: Victorian Government Finally Introduces Evidence Bill, 2008
By Colin Miller
It's taken 4 years, but the Victorian government has finally introduced the Evidence Bill, 2008, which, if passed, would make Victoria the 4th Australian jurisdiction (after the Commonwealth, NSW, ACT,…
EvidenceProf Blog
Forfeit Victory, Take 10: Illinois Forfeiture Bill Unlikely To Have Impact On Stacy Peterson Case In Light Of Giles Opinion
By Colin Miller
The headline of a Chicago Tribune story posted late last night boldly proclaims, "Stacy Peterson allies buoyed by bill on hearsay testimony." The problem is that I don't think that…
EvidenceProf Blog
Three Is The Magic Number: Supreme Court Of Rhode Island Affirms Hearsay Ruling, Despite 2/3 Of Trial Court’s Grounds Being Wrong
By Colin Miller
The recent opinion of Supreme Court of Rhode Island in State v. Barkmeyer, 2008 WL 2468804 (R.I. 2008), contains lengthy discussions of a number of interesting legal issues, but I…
EvidenceProf Blog
Georgia Rule: Supreme Court of Goergia Hears Oral Arguments On Alleged “Secret Rule” By Magistrate Judges
By Colin Miller
As an Atlanta Journal and Constitution story correctly notes, courts don't often hear cases pitting a district attorney against a lower court, but that is exactly the scenario with which…
EvidenceProf Blog
Article of Interest: Professor Philip K. Hamilton’s Should Statements Made by Patients During Psychotherapy Fall Within the Medical Treatment Hearsay Exception? An Interdisciplinary Critique
By Colin Miller
New England School of Law Professor Philip K. Hamilton recently published the fascinating article, Should Statements Made By Patients During Psychotherapy Fall Within the Medical Treatment Hearsay Exception? An Interdisciplinary…
EvidenceProf Blog
I Drink Your Milkshake!: Milkshake Murderer’s Attorney Argues Hong Kong Court Improperly Allowed Hearsay Testimony
By Colin Miller
A strange case from Hong Kong reveals that the region is dealing with the same evidentiary issue set to be heard soon by the United States Supreme Court. In 2003,…