Topic
Hearsay
406 published works
EvidenceProf Blog
Declare The Pennies On Your Eyes: Tax Case Reveals Interplay Between Rule 803(6) And Rule 1006
By Colin Miller
While I am completely clueless about all matters tax-related (I thank my wife Zoe for handling all of these matters), I thought I would do a tax-related post in (dis)honor…
EvidenceProf Blog
The Ice Pick Murderer: Ohio Court Finds Statements By Victim Admissible In Roommate Murder Trial
By Colin Miller
Jury selection is expected to begin today in the trial of an Ohio woman accused of stabbing her roommate in the head with an ice pick, and those jurors selected…
EvidenceProf Blog
Bullet In The Head: Illinois Judge Makes Seemingly Erroneous [EDIT: Correct] Hearsay Ruling In Attempted Murder Case
By Colin Miller
An Illinois judge has made a seemingly strange [EDIT: correct] hearsay ruling, which appears to have played a large role in a defendant being acquitted of the most serious charges…
EvidenceProf Blog
Bordertown: California Judge Excludes Cellmate Testimony About Jailhouse Confession
By Colin Miller
A judge in a California murder case has made a seemingly incorrect evidentiary ruling based upon the statement against interest exception to the rule against hearsay. Roger Clark is currently…
EvidenceProf Blog
The Accidental Expert: Missouri Court Finds Accident Reconstruction Report Partially Based Upon Hearsay To Be Inadmissible
By Colin Miller
According to the Court of Appeals of Missouri's recent opinion in State v. Bybee, 2008 WL 762224 (Mo.App. W.D. 2008), an accident reconstructionist cannot base a report or testimony upon…
Legal Profession Blog
Objection! Hearsay!
The Georgia Supreme Court held that the failure of defense counsel to object to improper hearsay testimony amounted to ineffective assistance of counsel and reversed a malice murder conviction. The…
EvidenceProf Blog
I Said , “M-I-S-T-R-I-A-L,” Mistrial: Pennsylvania Judge Declares Mistrial After “Hearsay” Testimony About Voice Mail
By Colin Miller
Here's a strange ruling from a Pennsylvania case. After Leslie Kerstetter's husband died of cancer, her alcohol and drug problems became severe enough to lead her to seek help through…
EvidenceProf Blog
Night At The Museum, Take 2: Tenth Circuit Finds Appellate Courts Should Be Especially Deferential To Hearsay Rulings
By Colin Miller
Yesterday, I wrote about the Tenth Circuit's recent opinion in United States v. Ary, 2008 WL 565437 (10th Cir. 2008). Today, I want to address another aspect of that case. …
EvidenceProf Blog
Night At The Museum: Tenth Circuit Finds Hearsay Within Hearsay Admissible In Museum Theft Case
By Colin Miller
The Tenth Circuit's recent opinion in United States v. Ary, 2008 WL 565437 (10th Cir. 2008), contains a combined application of the business records exception to the rule against hearsay…
EvidenceProf Blog
It’s Fun To Stay At The YMCA: Wisconsin Judge Allows “Hearsay Within Hearsay” Testimony
By Colin Miller
A Wisconsin judge has made a seemingly confusing hearsay ruling in a preliminary hearing in a gang shooting case. Eighteen year-old Darrell Jackson was shot twice outside a Janesville, Wisconsin…