Topic
Joinder
36 published works
Patents Post-Grant
New PTAB Precedent Panel Conducts First Hearing
By Scott McKeown, Scott McKeown Wolf Greenfield
Issue Joinder Practices Poised to Reset As previously discussed, the Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB) is now reconsidering its issue joinder practices. These practices were the subject of significant…
PTAB Law Blog
PTAB Prepares to Convene its First Precedential Opinion Panel to Address Joinder Under 35 U.S.C. § 315(c)
The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (“the PTAB” or “the Board”) is preparing for its first instance of the newly created Precedential Opinion Panel (POP). Proppant Express Invs., LLC v.…
Life Science Legal Report
PTAB Holds that 35 U.S.C. § 315(c) Prevents Same-Party Joinder of Issues to An Instituted IPR
IPR petitioners Proppant Express Investments, LLC and Proppant Express Solutions, LLC (collectively, “PropX”) have a pending instituted inter partes review (IPR) on certain claims of U.S. Patent No. 9,511,929 (“the…
MS Litigation Review & Commentary
Commercial Litigation is …..
A lot's happened in the legal world since I last had time to blog. The U.S. Supreme Court took a lesson from the Miss. Supreme Court's playbook on joinder. Meanwhile,…
Patents Post-Grant
Mandamus Questions PTAB Joinder Practices
Patentee Argues Joinder Statute Does Not Excuse Late IPR Petitions There has been a fair amount of controversy regarding issue joinder practices at the PTAB. But, to date, the language…
AIA Blog
Federal Circuit Confirms That Same PTAB Panel Can Institute and Decide an IPR
In Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien LP, a split Federal Circuit panel held that having the same PTAB panel that instituted an inter partes review also decide its merits does…
PTABWatch
Split PTAB Ruling Allows Parties to Join Their Own Petitions
By Eric M. Brusca, Ph.D., Michael J. Allikian
An expanded, split panel of the PTAB recently decided that it may be appropriate to join the same party’s serially-filed IPR petitions into a single proceeding, even when one such…
Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
So-Called “Porno Troll’s” Attempt at Joinder, Discovery Shot Down
Tired of using Mosley v. General Motors for an illustration of joinder under Rule 20? The D.C. Circuit has provided a great new case. The court quaintly began its opinion:Generally…
Chicago IP Litigation
Court Maintains Secrecy of Copyright Doe Defendants Because of “Substantial Possibilit[y]” of Misnaming
Osiris Entertainment, LLC v. Does 1-38, No. 13 C 4901, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Aug. 20, 2013) (Tharp, J.). Judge Tharp granted plaintiff Osiris Entertainment's Fed. R. Civ. P 26(d)…
PostGrant-Counsel Blog
Lack of Speed Kills – The Dangers of Waiting in the PTAB
By Ben Snitkoff
Since we last discussed joinder in inter partes review (IPR) proceedings, the Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB) has released two interesting orders that expand the case law on the…