Topic
Joinder
36 published works
PostGrant-Counsel Blog
The More the Merrier – Joinder under the AIA
By Ben Snitkoff
Under the America Invents Act (AIA), parties to an Inter Partes Review (IPR) or Post Grant Review (PGR) may move to join pending IPR or PGR proceedings. See 37 C.F.R.…
Virgin Islands Law Blog
Indispensable Parties, Joinder, and Unidentified Heirs
By Tom Bolt
This case stemmed from the tax sale of property known as “No. 5 Estate Sans Souci and Guinea Gut, No. 9 & 10 Cruz Bay Quarter, St. John, United States…
Drug & Device Law
Consolidation Request Backfires On Plaintiffs
By Bexis
Sometimes bad enough should just be left alone. That’s what a bunch of plaintiffs (and/or their lawyers) found out the other day from the Seventh Circuit in Abbott Laboratories, v. Alexander, Nos. 12-8020,…
SDNY Blog
Judge Marrero Severs Multiple John Doe Defendants in Copyright Case, Limits Discovery
In an opinion last week, Judge Marrero took a new approach to the vexing question of the appropriateness of joinder of multiple John Doe defendants accused of copyright violations in…
SDNY Blog
Judges Scheindlin and McMahon Refuse to Reconsider Joinder of John Doe Defendants
In two orders on Monday, Judge Scheindlin and Judge McMahon reinforced their position -- as reported on before in this space -- that individual unknown John Does could not be…
Chicago IP Litigation
Common Use of Bit Torrent Sufficient for Joinder
Judge Darrah granted in part Does defendant's Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss plaintiff Hard Drive Production's ("HDP") complaint accusing Does of infringing HDP's copyrighted video via BitTorrent.…
Retail Patent Litigation
Multiple Defendant Cases Die Hard
In September, I wrote that the America Invents Act's ("AIA") main impact upon patent litigation would be the new joinder rule prohibiting suing multiple, unrelated defendants in a single case.…
Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
Effron on The Shadow Rules of Joinder
By Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
I have posted my article The Shadow Rules of Joinder to SSRN.Abstract: The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide litigants with procedural devices for joining claims and parties. Several of these…
Chicago IP Litigation
Similar Products Sold by Unrelated Defendants Not Warrant Joinder in Patent Cases
Rude d/b/a ABT Sys., LLC v. Lux Prods. Corp., No. 09 C 6957, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. Jan. 12, 2011) (Norgle, J.). Judge Norgle granted defendant Emerson Climate Technologies' ("ECT")…
Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
Joined at the Hip?: Is the Fraudulent Misjoinder Doctrine the Fraudulent Joinder Doctrine’s Twin or a Red-Headed Stepchild?
By Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
Courts have long recognized fraudulent joinder as an exception to the complete diversity rule....Fraudulent joinder occurs when a plaintiff files a frivolous or illegitimate claim against a non-diverse defendant solely…